I liked Keatings and would've kept him, but he wanted to play which is fair enough. But comparing him to Reilly is insane considering Reilly hasn't had a real chance and has found it difficult to break in ahead of Juanma and Sow which is exactly what Keating's would struggle with as well. Without setting the heather alight, he's still managed 2 goals in 4 starts this season which isn't bad and scored roughly the same amount as Keatings over the previous two seasons in the Championship.
We don't miss Keatings and are doing just fine with our current squad. John Baird has 4 more league goals than Keatings this season, maybe we should regret not signing him?