I didn't mind PJ, he was as good as the loan keepers we had, certainly Kinnear who he couldn't get a game in front of. That said he was out for a while with injury, when he got back fit McGlynn seemed to think he had lost some confidence. He was a permanent signing so to not get a game in front of a loan keeper probably made his mind up to try pastures new. I'd be amazed if McGlynn hasn't already had talks with MacDonald in a player/coach role as Bobby Geddes had just left the club. Not sure I'd want MacDonald back but realistically he's probably as good a keeper as your going to get in league 1. And we currently have no keepers.