It's true that he's looked out of sorts for us in a few caps over the last two years. I don't think the answer is leaving him out though. Totally agree that Gilmour does seem to fit the Scotland side more naturally. Could we find a midfield shape that utilises McT, Gilly Bilmour and McGregor? Hard to see it to be honest without leaving the front two a bit isolated.
You would leave out McGinn?
Always gonna provoke an amazed reaction from somebody. We have 3 excellent midfielders for 3 spots.
Personally I'd leave out McGregor, despite him playing so well recently.
I'd have mctominay holding, excellent against Tottenham recently in the role, gilmour link guy, mcginn pushing on.
You could make an argument for any of the 3 really.
As long as gilmour is in every selection.