Stewart Whyte
-
Posts
38 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Events
Store
Posts posted by Stewart Whyte
-
-
Wishing everyone involved with Montrose FC all the best for the season.
5 -
Will we take any loan players?
The season starts this weekend and transfer window closes on 2nd September. After a pre-season look at their squads Premiership clubs are looking at trimming down to a realistic size and getting youngsters a development loan.
Montrose are nearly there - we have 20 players (2 GK, 6 Def, 6 Mid and 6 Forwards). Last year we had 3 loanees; all who added to our squad but, I don’t think we’ll see 3 this year. Loan players are a short term fix but, each year you have to start again. Loan players must be played as part of the loan - at times their inexperience is not the best thing for the given situation but, more importantly it blocks the playing times for our squad.
If we have playing time for developing youngsters the time can be used by Montrose to improve our young forwards.
That’s not to say we shouldn’t take any loans, they have their place but, I don’t see it being 3 this year.
1 -
Went home cold and uninspired by a poor game on Saturday but, wanted to reflect before I shared my thoughts. Firstly the score and perhaps the performance are not they way to assess a pre-season match - not that both don’t matter to fans who have paid good money to travel and enter a ground. Pre-season is a chance to integrate new signings, evaluate the shape of the squad and to experiment. To that end it was a success with all new players getting decent playing time while the seasoned vets got game time into their legs. Lewis Milne was tried at just in front of the defence and while he had a couple of good passes we lacked guile further up without him. Noticeable that our good spell was when he was playing behind the frontline. Dillon strolled through the game and I like Webster, Ballantyne and Lyons. I’m not piling on McLean - strikers take the longest to develop, it is the most prized position and few teams in the SPFL have reliable ones. Where we were weaker than normal was play in and into the box. No point sugar coating it Aaron spilled the ball for the first one and we gave away a pen - both goals were very avoidable. Cove were up for it for the new manager and will survive in L2 this year. I’m in Edinburgh this week, so will miss Arbroath; I hope SP continues to give the full squad playing time, especially the new ones and tries things out. Good sides make intelligent use of their pre-season. We start proper on 3rd August. The priority is 8th.
3 -
Quietly and without a fuss SP continues to build a very sound squad - good at the back, feisty in midfield and good on the wings. Others sides have added far more players but will they be a team? At least one of the teams that are investing will implode when they don’t make a fast start. We are strengthening a side that made the play offs last year, I feel confident we can repeat. Looking forward to Cove tomorrow.
3 -
-
I wonder if any Montrose fans were calling for Petrie's head after 10 games?
None.1 -
51 minutes ago, Aidan said:
Jamie Redman has left Montrose to sign for Cove.
a very good signing for Cove. Will give them experience, leadership and midfield drive. He had become a squad player for us - a very valuable one - and his starts would have been rotational next season, so I can see his POV. Makes midfield reinforcements even more necessary. Also shows the wisdom of retaining Liam Callaghan.
0 -
I fell into the early close season trap of seeing other sides announce new players and thinking what about us. We have see others sides in L1 fail, in their terms, by a high turnover of players. We grew by keeping a good squad together and have prospered through familiarity and players enjoying themselves; coupled with good coaching, tactical flexibility and leadership. Despite last year being a very good financial year I would be shocked if we didn't remain one of the smallest player budgets in L1. Cammie Ballantyne alone means we have had a good window. Having said that I think we need younger legs in midfield to be groomed for when our current crop hang up their boots. There will likely be signings and the right loanee or two. In Stewart Petrie and the Board we trust.
5 -
Williamson could be freed from pars,him at rb and Steeves from Montrose at lb,but unlikely
Very unlikely, Steeves signed a new contract and is a fan favourite. Why would he go to a team below us.0 -
It's not going to happen but big big questions to be asked about McGlynn. To claim we have the nucleus of a good squad is absolutely crazy.
And he’d be really crazy to say he hasn’t. The reality is many have to stay. Look at Arbroath and Forfar this season. 4 or so signings to an established squad is the only way to improve unless there is buckets loads of cash. You do, though, have to hit on your signings, and avoid big injuries. Raith are a good L1 side who will be challenging for the title next season.1 -
I was 8 in 1978 and I have a distinct memory of asking my Dad who he wanted to win in the final - Argentina or Holland, or more accurately I have a distinct memory of his answer. Holland, because we’d beaten them so we’d be the best team in the world. Not the same thing but, when I was thinking about writing my post today that story came to mind.
The Mo’s outstanding season saw us play the two best sides in the Championship. We only lost 1-3 away to the winners - Ross County and the great Scottish Cup occasion at Links Park, 0-4 to play off winners Dundee United. We beat the 9th best team 2-1 at home before getting a hiding away.
There is a clear gap between us and the top of the Championship but, by no means is it massive. We are a good L1 side and will fear no one in the division next year and there won’t be many sides glad to draw us in the cups. If SP gets the recruits he’s after we will challenge for the title, if not we should be mid-table.1 -
The first one seems to be the hot favourite but it's not for me. I would have it last.
I like the bottom left one. Very similar to the current strip which I like.
I voted for the fourth one too.0 -
I reckon we should stop having a go at Seagull. Only the week before he was voted MOTM and his form has generally been good this season. Yes a few hoolies here and there but some game saving efforts as well. He's a decent keeper at L1 level. When he first came he wouldn't come off his line for crosses and I was furious with him but since Jim Butter came back Flem has improved dramatically - but as I say he is a L1 keeper for a reason. It was a well hit hard free kick and despite the wall Flem still had to cover his left as well for a dink over the wall - credit to the lad who hit it.
My view too. He will have competition next year but, I’ll be okay if he beats him out, as he did this year.
0 -
One less competition as Josh Skelly is back out on loan for the rest of the season. My two-penneth worth - we can all see that we are missing a regular box scorer and SP will know it better than anyone. According to reports on here we had the money for a transfer of Mark McGuigan from Stenhousemuir but, he preferred to see what he is offered in the summer. So SP used some of that money on Russell McLean, a player he had a look at acquiring in the summer. My only reservation is he wasn't starting for Peterhead from what I can see. The Peterhead thread has people regretting his move - which is a good sign. All in all I welcome him to the Mo and looking forward to seeing him in action.
0 -
Excellent Jim Duffy interview on Radio Scotland today. Worth a listen on BBC Sounds for fans of all lower league clubs.
1 -
Euan Henderson signed on for the rest of the season. Excellent news. The bright young Hearts loanee grew into being the left-wing of the forward three in the post-Annan blossoming of our season. Delighted to have you back Euan.
4 -
The day will come when Stewart Petrie moves on but, it is not this day.
3 -
Happy days. Was getting the fear there yesterday.
Me too!0 -
Stewart Petrie won SPFL manager of the month for December and Martin Rennie won player of the month. Outstanding! Congratulations to both, well earned. Mon the Mo!
5 -
A bit of a callous question in this, the season of goodwill, is it not?
Petrie stood by his men, stood by his promises to Ralph Milne, lost Templeman to the ravages of old father time, lost Ballantyne to Dumbarton. People, including myself thought he had made the wrong decision(s) but what did we know? Petrie would appear to be the best manager the Mo have had for as long as I can remember and by a country mile.
He has tried to bring in other players to strengthen the squad, who for various reasons did not end up coming to the club.
Hopefully, with things going reasonably well at the middle of the season, we may be a marginally more attractive proposition than during the last transfer window.
At this stage, we are competing at this level. We will need to keep up with others who are seeking to strengthen their challenge too.
I reckon Petrie knows what he's doing and will continue to do right by whoever can continue to convince him they can do a decent job for him. I don't think we currently have any malcontented, girning, passengers on the playing staff - and that is testimony to the calibre of management and quality of the current ethos at the club. For at least one long-suffering Montrose fan, that is an enviable position to find ourselves in and one for which I wouldn't trade places, with any other team in this league and more besides.
Well said. Stewart Petrie has earned our trust. Squad harmony cannot be underestimated. Every player watches how the others are treated.
0
Mighty Montrose FC 2019 / 2020
in Scottish League 1 General Chatter
Posted
I missed the Airdrie game as I had an interview - which I got. Sadly it means working on Saturdays. I am really missing the games already but, nothing can be done. I’m reliant on the people who post on Pie and Bovril, social media and MontroseTV. Won’t be forever but, it is the next two years. Mon the Mo!