Jump to content

500ClubCraig

Gold Members
  • Posts

    23
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by 500ClubCraig

  1. League Reconstruction 20/21 season
     

    Booted out at the committee stage and never got off the ground when SuperBudge was going to revolutionise Scottish Football. 
    Would only have happened if it had been included in the original SPFL Resolution to end the leagues.

    The fear has to be as the current situation unfolds that it may require to be revisited, especially for the lower leagues, as most clubs will not be able to play with no paying fans. Don’t see crowds at Sporting events for some time to come, especially given recent events in Aberdeen.

  2. THE JAMBO POET

    This sort of nonsense has been stoked by the club Statement as written by AB, she should no better than refer to recent events as a battle and winning “the WAR”.

    She needs to rain it in ASAP, the only saving grace is 99% of this bluster is keyboard warriors.

    As for a War she should have visited the local Hospital ITU unit a few weeks ago and then she would have seen a battlefield of a different sort.

  3. 1 hour ago, djchapsticks said:

    I see you've played knifey spoony before... 

    Yes. It’s been a good way to pass the time when at Tynecastle over the last few seasons 🔪 🥄 👍
    Hopefully  they will make face coverings mandatory when we get back to games and I can shout what I like at our quality, hard working players, safe in the knowledge I can’t be 😷 identified by the Budgie Polis 

  4. 2 hours ago, Yorky said:

    There was an interesting statistic given the other day showing points in the Premiership over the last 10 years and Hearts were 7th behind the like of Motherwell, St Johnstone, and Kilmarnock, that’s pretty amazing given the huge difference in budgets. I keep reading that other clubs fans are envious of Hearts because they are able to compete with Rangers and Celtic for the league, that’s clearly not the case. Hearts have been an absolute failure of a football club now over a long period of time, that’s also just a fact. I really feel some of the support base would do well to Show a little more humility instead of trying to put down all the other “ Diddy teams” because  they really are not all that. A diddy club like Motherwell who have been in the top flight since 1985 are actually a far more successful club.

    Was the interesting statistics simply the total Premiership points earned by each club over the last ten seasons?

  5. 1 hour ago, Green Day said:

    It is run under the rules for arbitration, which means it has to be entirely independent.

    The two sides choose from the Tribunal Candidate List and select a judge, solicitor, advocate of at least 10 years standing as chair.

    None of this was "handed down by Lord Clark" you fucking dipshit, its how the system actually works.

    Thank you for taking the time to comment on my post, the Arbitration process has been widely reported in recent days but your pertinent and helpful summary is appreciated.

    Perhaps I may suggest that you are a little more accurate when quoting and at least make sure it is from the same post (“handed down by Lord Clark”) or you also may be referred to as a fucking dipshit.

  6. 50 minutes ago, TonyFerrino said:

    End result of these weeks and weeks of Jambos tears and snotters will be no more than your parachute payment.  What a massively entertaining waste of time.  It was a good laugh, wasn't it?

    I’m sure a lot of people would be delighted if the only thing they had to worry about in recent months was this charade.

    My main point is it could all so easily have been avoided.

    From a football perspective for myself it has at least meant the departure of Daniel Stendel and a number of players and back room staff that won’t be missed.  
    Some massive mistakes been made at Tynecastle throughout the League season, that had they been made by a rival then yes I’d also be having a good laugh at also, fair play.
     

     

  7. 13 minutes ago, welshbairn said:

    Didn't cost them much to contest it, the panel would have demanded it anyway. Made it easier for the judge to throw the case back to the panel while giving the posture of neutrality.

    Lord Clark rejected the SPFL premise that persons with footballing interest should preside over this matter. Instead, it would be an independent (from the SFA or SPFL) tribunal. While Hearts and Partick Thistle were unable to get the hearings in open court as they wanted, they got their way in their request for documents to be uncovered relating to the case before it is heard by a tribunal.

  8. 7 minutes ago, welshbairn said:

    he did exactly what the SPFL wanted.

    Really? Why did they contest the request  for documents to be released then.

     “In these unprecedented circumstances, it is, in my view, open to me under the inherent jurisdiction of the court, to make an order for the recovery of documents. I do not accept the contention of [the respondents] that granting such an order is not competent; the issue is before the court. I have had full regard to the points made on behalf of those parties in opposition to the motion for Hearts and Partick Thistle for recovery of documents.”

  9. 21 minutes ago, welshbairn said:

    The judge said that the arbitration panel would be entitled to demand the same, but he thought he'd speed it up a little to help them out. Nice of him to throw Hearts a few sweeties after telling them where they should have gone in the first place, and gently asking the SFA not to be too harsh on them for breaking the rules.

    At the Court of Session hearing, Lord Clark ruled in favour of Hearts and Partick Thistle's motion to release certain documents relating to the case.
    The clubs have succeeded in their petition for the recovery of documents relevant to orders they sought in terms of the Companies Act 2006.

    He noted that, by default, rule 28 of the Scottish Arbitration Rules allowed an arbitration tribunal to grant disclosure of documents, but that this rule could be excluded by the parties.

     

    Putting all that aside the point I was making is that Scottish Football didn’t need to be in this position. 

  10. Reconstruction could and should have been part of the Resolution presented by ND and the SPFL Board to end the League’s.

    It could have been in the simple form of 12, 12, 10, 10 if only the lower leagues were ended and 14,10,10, 10 if all leagues were ended. Could easily added that any other format, that was agreed by the members, which For example didn’t see a Club playing in a lower league From 19/20 Season could be used instead.

    What was presented and the way it was then handled can only be described as farce. 13 clubs, more than 30% of all teams represented by the SPFL - expressed serious doubts in the executive and wanted an inquiry into their actions.

    The continual dangling of the reconstruction carrot to the clubs worse affected was most probably nothing more than a delaying tactic to try and avoid them following through with the threat of Legal action.
    Had Hearts and Partick gone straight to the SFA for arbitration then the legal requirement for all related documents to be made available would not have been in place, clearly something their Legal Teams feel are very important.

    All Clubs had the opportunity to put their preferences on reconstruction to the committee that was initially set up.

    We will soon find out what the final outcome is but regardless the damage done could so easily have been avoided.

     

  11. Glad to have got such a warm welcome.

    I was making the point that whilst multiple clubs are blaming each other -   “Doncaster, nobody seems to be laying the blame at his door yet the farcical resolution forced through by him and his SPFL Board is the reason Scottish Professional Football is in this mess. “

    Wasn’t having a go at any other clubs specifically, don’t agree with most of the sentiment on JKB at present but can see how the strength of feeling there has got to this point.

    The SPFL clubs pay ND in excess of £7k per week and should be expecting a whole lot more than he has delivered.

    As for me making racial remarks? Not aware that I had and certainly never purposely did so.

    Whatever the outcome of Arbitration the game as a whole has a very challenging period ahead as does the whole of society, how well and how quickly Scottish Football heals these wounds could prove critical.

  12. 17 minutes ago, Lebowski said:

    I’m not sure how many times it has to be written, but Doncaster is employed by the SPFL to take the heat from clubs when something unpopular is done. If clubs didn't have Doncaster, they'd replace him with a fucking clone if they could.

    They could replace him with a 🤡 never mind a clone and be in a much better place.

  13. IF the ending of the 19/20 League Seasons had been done with a Resolution that had clear and proper guidance given by the SPFL Board, all options made available, sufficient time given for proper consideration, voted upon with integrity and with the ethos of duty of care to all 42 member clubs, not to mention within the boundaries of the Law, then this ridiculous situation would never have arisen.

    Fair play to Neil Doncaster, nobody seems to be laying the blame at his door yet the farcical resolution forced through by him and his SPFL Board is the reason Scottish Professional Football is in this mess. 

    This will not end well and could so easily have been avoided on more than one occasion. 

    Time will tell who has to “take their medicine”, unfortunately that won’t be the overpaid Chief Executive who has made such a mess of it.

×
×
  • Create New...