Thing is, this kinda gets to the heart of what some fans deem to be "success" - and I know we had these debates between Hibs and Dons fans when McInnes was about to leave.
People may ask what we (Hibs) deem a good season - if coming third, qualifying for Europe and decent cup runs would be deemed a success?
Some say "yes", and if it came around next season would be ahead of our budget (which will be 4th or 5th next season).
To me, thats an accountants answer.
As a fan? Winning stuff is all that really counts - St Johnstone have finished 5th, got European football and won two cups.
You say they are not a great side based on the fact they dont play sparkling football - for me, great sides find a way to win - and St Johnstone did that, and deserve every accolade they and Davidson are getting.
Thats what I call success - you dont get to put 3rd place in the trophy cabinet.