Jump to content

Terry_Tibbs

Gold Members
  • Posts

    619
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by Terry_Tibbs

  1. 1 hour ago, VictorOnopko said:

    That's simply not good enough, though, and saying it doesn't mean it would be the case. How could it be? You can't divorce deep-held personal beliefs from opining on difficult social questions.

    To be fair to her, she shouldn't really be in politics never mind trying to take charge of a country with the completely fruitloop views she holds.

    As opposed to sensible policies like allowing children to transition without their parents consent.

  2. 17 hours ago, HighlandQueen said:

    To me looks more likely he will stay due to Board inertia and lack of cash to pay him off. In which case time to get rid of that utter dud Murray and get a proper experienced assistant with any type of ability in…

    It doesn't matter who his assistant is. Bartley is utterly intransigent. He's got football management cracked and it's everyone else's fault we're "utter dugmeat".

  3. 1 hour ago, Ye Olde Hamiltonian said:

    How has big Joel been getting on?

    Quite a few Accies punters roasted him,but they also roasted Dylan Tait and Joe McGlynn…if only there was a link to all three eh?

    I don’t think he is as bad as some of our fans made him out to be and would do a job for plenty League 1/2 teams.

     

    He's missed a couple of sitters. He's powerful and quick, with decent movement, but his finishing lets him down. He'd probably average 10 goals in league 1 if played central. Bartley had him playing on the wing. I'd give him pass marks compared to some of the shite i've seen this season.

  4. 1 hour ago, HighlandQueen said:

    Sadly I think you are right. He is a terrific orator but has zero skill at this level as a football manager, sadly. I like a lot of others was drawn in by the compelling narrative and young, cool, professional look but there is no substance. I don’t think he has a clue how to get us out of this. We are a full time team with a reasonable budget. How are we third bottom? 

    In other words, you fancy him and have given him more credit than he deserves. Even now you can't be objective. He has no oratory skills whatsoever nor have i seen evidence of this supposed intelligence he has over our previous managers. If you actually listen to his interviews, he drones on in a monotone until he gets bored or the interview runs out of time. At the beginning of the season, when his message was positive, i didn't hear any conviction or passion in his voice. It was as if he was reading the ingredients on a pack of biscuits. George Galloway is an example of a talented orator. He could read a list of ingredients and make it sound like poetry. I know i'd switch off if i had to listen to Bartley droning on in training everyday.

  5. A change would be best for both parties. If Martindale takes you down - and he doesn't get it right in the championship - he might never work again as manager. He has clearly peaked at your club. If he leaves now he avoids having a relegation on his CV. Last night's improvement could prove to be another false dawn like the performance against Hearts. It could potentially get embarrassing if you don't hit form soon. It would be best to give a young manager like Dougie Imrie a free hit at the remainder of the season. Just my tuppenceworth with no axe to grind.

  6. 19 hours ago, SUPERSOUTH said:

    Annan sign free agent defender Rico Quitongo. 

    Rico had played as a triallist twice in December for Annan. 

    Good to see Rico back playing after that injury last season.

    I hope Annan find a way to stay up in the playoffs.

    Finishing below Edinburgh City would be nothing short of a disgrace.

  7. 4 minutes ago, 19QOS19 said:

    Ah right. We've just to judge him on his successes? 'mon in Billy!

    The overall picture is that he's done alright.  We're hurtling towards league 2 at this rate. We're either going to take punt on someone with no experience or appoint a manager who's been sacked previously. Overall, we could do worse than Dodds. Whether he'd take the job is a different matter.

  8. 1 hour ago, 19QOS19 said:

    Not sure what Billy Dodds has done to convince folk he'd be a good appointment tbh. Having a look at his managerial career he has a 43% win rate. Bartley currently sitting on 46% (which will absolutely continue to fall though and he's had less games). But Allan Johnstone has a 44% win rate. I reckon Dodds was in charge of a better side than anything we've had at Palmerston recently as well. Really don't think he'd be able to turn us around. But then I don't know who could realistically turn this shitshow around. 

    Cup final as a manager and two cup finals as an assistant.  Made the playoffs with Inverness in his two full seasons as manager.

    Judging him solely on the beginning of this season is no different to judging Mourinho solely on his final few months at a club.

  9. 3 hours ago, 19QOS19 said:

    He can't answer questions he's not been asked tbf. That comes down to the interviewer but as has been said, if it's a club interview they aren't going to really ask the pressing questions. 

    He hasn't accepted any culpability.  It's just empty words. He doesn't need to be asked what mistakes he's made in order to own up to them. Clearly the club's media representative isn't going to ask him why it's his fault. He freely elaborates on the mistakes of others. I don't recall him being asked what the players are doing in their spare time but he was quick to opine on that.

×
×
  • Create New...