Jump to content

bpdon

Gold Members
  • Posts

    630
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by bpdon

  1. 23 minutes ago, RandomGuy. said:

    I've never once seen a referee allow "play to develop" like that if they see a foul in the box on the defending side.

    Not once since VAR came in.

    Exactly. Refs never let play develop when they see a foul on a defender or keeper deep in their own box. The chances of that situation developing in favour of the victim are absolutely minuscule to zero, so they call it immediately. 

    It’s not often I’m in agreement with Michael Stewart but today is one of those days. It’s an incredibly soft foul and the way it was awarded was bizarre.

    Thankfully we found a way to score in open play which will take the attention away from the officials and this decision. Maybe.

    Totally agree with what you said about Roos too. He visibly wilted between the sticks and his attempts were lame and half hearted. 

  2. 2 minutes ago, LuboMoravcik said:

    CCV was clearly in control, he was about to clear it. Wake up and smell the coffee, pal. It was never ever a penalty. The Scales hand ball was a stronger shout.

    Woh, woh, woh. Rewind. Not only did CCV hoof Hoillet on the back of the calf (hint: that means Hoillet was between CCV and the ball)…. you went even further in your earlier post and said that it was a foul on CCV because Hoillet came into his space. It’s something stronger than coffee you have been smelling. 

  3. 23 minutes ago, LuboMoravcik said:

    He didn't try to intercept the ball. He tried to win a penalty. Correct decision was made. I'll enjoy the tears over it though.

    The ball was loose - CVV wasn’t in control of it. The whole thing happened in milliseconds and Hoilett was perfectly entitled to put himself between CCV and the ball. Players put their bodies across, and in the way of, each other all the time. It’s not some p1shy space stealing micro aggression - it’s how football works.

  4. 2 minutes ago, LuboMoravcik said:

    Aberdeen player makes no attempt to play the ball, CCV does. Aberdeen player hasn't touched the ball. He only gets hurt because he moves into CCV's space. If you think that's a penalty you're an absolute moron.

    Ehh. So every attempt to intercept a loose ball is a foul because you step into someone’s space? Have you listened to yourself?

  5. 6 minutes ago, DukDukGoose said:

    Nicky Devlin giving away a penalty? No way!

    Lost count of how many pens he has conceded now. He gifted Hibs an equaliser a few weeks back too. 

    Back to basics performance today. Blood and thunder, grit and graft. Other than the top bin ping for the goal, there was nae quality - none at all. Frustrating to fail from a self inflicted wound(again) after doing the hard yards for 92mins.

    Not going to moan about VAR because I thought it looked like a pen. But the decision took ages. Surely if it takes that long, it’s not a clear and obvious error?

  6. 7 minutes ago, Flybhoy said:

    First one is an horrendous challenge, could have been an extremely serious injury for Alistair Johnston, the Hibs booing him being carried off on a stretcher not knowing what day it is really is beyond stupid, reminds me of a similar challenge on Ryan Christie at a semi against Aberdeen about five years ago by, if memory serves me correctly Lewis Ferguson? No penalty as it was in the middle of the pitch but a red card and Christie genuinely looked like he'd done ten rounds in a UFC octagon.

    It was Dominic Ball that nutted Christie. The other similar example that springs to mind is the Mackay-Steven and Boyata clash which was in the box in the 2018 Betfred final.

  7. 1 hour ago, 1GregStewart said:

    Have watched back the highlights today after being at the game, and have to say Roos should be doing better with the 2nd. It’s a save he can’t not make despite the swerve and his body is in position to make a more forceful clearance. 
     

    Agree with this. It was a good strike and it did move late on but he had a clear view of it from 25-30 yards out and he was well positioned to deal with it. It wasn't as poor as the pathetic first goal, but it was another costly misread.

     

  8. 7 minutes ago, BucksburnDandy said:

    I agree fully, the pace on that shot from Lawrence was difficult and Kelle Roos isn't Joe Lewis in his prime or Danny Ward.

     

    The first and even the two he got away with were all worse examples of not pushing the ball wide.

    I know what you mean. It was a crisp hit but he saw that shot coming from a long way out and it was fairly central. He has to push that wide or round the post. It was poor. 

  9. Yeah, hanging on to Miovski is a relief. Everything else about January has been just awful. Struggling to think of another transfer window that has felt so flat and underwhelming.

    With no management team, it was never going to be easy to sneak in some much needed last minute signings, which makes it all the more galling that it took the board so long to let the guillotine fall on Robson's role.

  10. 10 hours ago, DrewDon said:

    It is not exactly a new thing this season, but what struck me tonight is just how desperate and messy we are when we have the ball. It is so disjointed, lacking any convincing patterns of play, and pitifully predictable. We have successfully combined being really bad with being really ineffective. 

    Yup. Over looking the very, very infrequent collectively good team displays, it has been this way for almost a calendar year now. Like last night, too often we have churned out these one dimensional and painfully predictable performances. The management and coaches have to accept they are culpable for this.

    That said, also like last night, we can't overlook the individual errors that just keep compounding. Roos and MacDonald had stinkers for Aschcroft's equalizer. That's two midweek games in a row Roos has wilted under a cross ball and cost us 4 points.

     

×
×
  • Create New...