Stan Bo
-
Posts
193 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Events
Store
Posts posted by Stan Bo
-
-
16 minutes ago, btb said:
OMG - I'm about to make a post sorta defending Stubbsy!
The problem with Stubbsy's philosophy was that he "threw the baby out with the bathwater" in terms of destroying the morale of our 17/18 Championship winning team. If you look at the last two matches of his tenure (against Hertz & Livi) we started with 5 of his EPL Academy acquisitions which is 4 too many. That market is still a decent one for a club of our stature though - look at Thierry Small last season.
As an aside - Oran Kearney!
I don't actually think that was Stubbs main failing with us. Out of all the signings Alfie Jones and Hayden Coulson clearly had ability, and they came from big teams academys. It was that he thought the way to succeed in the league was to fill the team with Athletes, big, tall, strong quick players who would run over the opposition. Guys like Kpekawa, NBM, Heaton, Cooke and Willock. The problem with that was that a) for a few of them their attitude was dreadful and b) they drastically lacked any football ability.
0 -
6 minutes ago, btb said:
Fair doos - I'd actually managed to forget about Stubbs.
Lucky you
0 -
9 minutes ago, houston_bud said:
Darryl Duffy. I don't think he ever actually played, then got put out on loan to Airdrie. It was a strange signing.
Yeah I'm probably being a bit harsh, but made about 3 sub appearances then left. For some reason he popped in my head.
0 -
19 minutes ago, btb said:
This has the potential to be our worst signing since Dougie Imrie.
Not even close
Heaton, Kpekawa, King, Brock-Marsden, Kellermam, Rogers, Edwards, Marwood, Duffy, Hippolyte, Hutton, Carswell
could go on for ages. Think that's just Stubbs and Rae
1 -
2 minutes ago, Mac28 said:
Possibly 433? Kenny LB, Kiltie, CBM and O'Hara midfield. olusanya and Sutherland out wide?
0 -
It's a tough one on Baccus. All saints fans can see his worth from his performances each week. But hes just turned 25 and has played 30-35 games in Europe. Whoever signs him is taking a punt to a degree.
Compare him to Ali McCann who St Johnstone got about £1m for (I think) who had played about 100 games, was a good 3 or 4 years younger and had 2/3 years left on his contract.
I know the £275k was a guess from someone but anything close to 300-500k isn't the worst business in the world especially if we can put in a decent percentage of his next sale
1 -
That is criminal defending
0 -
For really long spells that was just awful. Whilst it was a bit smash and grab saying it was the most undeserved win ever is just embarrassing. We dominated Motherwell far more in the first game and lost to a sucker punch.
Missing Ayunga and potentially Main and Strain is going to be a nightmare.
0 -
Wouldn’t be keen for Kiltie to leave unless Robinson has a replacement lined up. Don’t think he suits the midfield 3 the way we are currently set up. 100% his best work is as a 10.
Agree with those above that he allows us to change shape and can have an impact. I would imagine he’s not happy to sit on the bench. Arguably as 5th choice behind OHara, Baccus, Erhahon and Gogic
0 -
5 minutes ago, Silvio said:
Recently I am completely out of step with the majority of saints fans. Who would you drop from midfield to fit him in ? I think Ethan has started the season brilliantly and Keana is a real find.
Would you drop Main and go back to 1 up top ?
I just don't get it. He's just an average midfield player. Suppose last year he was playing alongside Power so that makes him look better I suppose.
I see him as a squad player, don't get all the excitement.
(Yes I am a miserable b*****d)
Find it amazing anyone that watched Gogic last year thinks he’s an average midfielder. Also offers a bit of cover at CH if needed but for me he will be one of the first names on the team sheet.
4 -
3 hours ago, SS77 said:
Stewart Gilmour has acted like a bit of a numpty at the last few meetings with the club.
Disagree with this
the current chairman was unbelievably unprofessional at the last meeting by not even having a copy of the accounts with him and not having the auditors at the meeting. SG for all he can be a bit of an arse, asked the same question about 10 times and no-one could answer it. I found it pretty poor from the current board and chairman
2 -
2 hours ago, RandomGuy. said:
This'll sound sarcastic when I don't mean it too, but any idea why we can't just re-use our season ticket cards from last season rather than getting a new one? I see a few other clubs seem to just update the card rather than replace it.
St Mirren changed the system last year and we all got cards with barcodes. It’s been confirmed we are getting new cards again however they will now have QR codes which mean they won’t need to replace the cards each year.
0 -
Line ups just posted by B&W army, definitely looks like 433
surprised Grieve didn’t have a few extra weeks off after international duty
0 -
9 minutes ago, djchapsticks said:
Anthony O'Connor linked according to a Morecambe fan over on BAWA.
He played for Aberdeen a few years back.
Is he not another centre half? Seems overkill to have Gallagher, Joe, Dunne, Fraser and one more
1 -
Also didn’t Robinson say he worked with Flynn at Oldham? So you would imagine they both know what each other is like
0 -
Back to football for a bit….
looking at the squad it’s good that we have the options to play a few different ways. Last pre season Goodwin went all in with the 352 by not signing any pacey wingers.
Hard to work out which way Robinson is going to start the season, his defensive signings (Gallagher/Strain) I would say point to a 3/5 at the back with Strain seemingly more a wing back like Tanser. If we go with the expected back 3 it would leave Fraser and Tait as the back up options. But looking at the midfield and up front it points to a 433. Potentially Gogic (or A.N other DM)/Baccus/OHara with Ayunga/Brophy/Olusanya up top, with Henderson, Erahon, Kiltie, Flynn and Reid the back up midfield options and Main and Grieve up top(think Kiltie could start to be fair depending on what type of player Baccus is if Gogic doesn’t sign)
so if we are to bring 1 more in I would expect it to be Gogic or another defensive type midfielder and that could it?
2 -
Was just looking at Gallaghers wiki page (I know…..) and it says he’s 6ft 6, that can’t be right surely?
0 -
Ryan Strain confirmed.
seems a real coup on paper, obviously had injury issues last season but hopefully he can stay injury free going forward
2 -
31 minutes ago, Arch Stanton said:
Aye but the new manager mustn't fancy him which is why McGinn has been told he can find a new club.
Hibs triggered the option on the 2nd June, Johnson was appointed well before that.
regardless, I would take Paul back.
1 -
Did Hibs not just trigger a clause in his contract for an extra year?
0 -
15 hours ago, djchapsticks said:
Another of our signing confirmations coming by end of the week - possibly even tomorrow as the scarf picture was apparently taken today.
Assume it’s one of the names that’s been widely reported?
0 -
39 minutes ago, Killiefan said:
Power to sign for Killie. Not sure I’m impressed but hey ho.
I was the same when we signed him last year when he had seemed to go right off the boil for you.
He started this season really well to be fair and was a far better footballer than I had ever given him credit for. Has been pretty poor for the last couple of months though, a decent option if he’s a back up for you.
0 -
Wonder if Lyness will be given a run if we get a positive result against Motherwell.
Even removing the red card I thought Alnwick was really poor today. A few times stayed on his line when he should have been out and came out when he shouldn’t have. Was poor (with the whole defence) against hearts as well.
and as for Robinson, the problem he will have is he isn’t the most likeable of managers. So when we go through bad runs he will get it tighter than Jim/Jack and Oran did. I can see him gutting the team in the summer as well…will be interesting
1 -
I find it amazing anyone would swap McCarthy for Dunne at the moment. Dunne has been absolutely superb since going to a back 4, and up til he got his injury McCarthy wasn’t on the best of form.
Apart from injury I can’t see McCarthy getting back in at all.
4
The St. Mirren FC 2023/24 thread
in Scottish Premiership General Chatter
Posted
Bedeau is a left footed centre half. We already have Dunne and Taylor. Would assume we will go back for Bedeau next summer. I would say it's McMenamin, Fletcher and possibly Sule