I would argue strongly Hatate did impede/challenge Findlay in playing the ball, if Hatate wasn’t there then he’s got enough time/space to control it then pass/hoof it to f**k.
Even if Hatate is trying to “get out of the way” as the idiots on Sportscene put it, Hatate has still forced Findlay into the playing the ball.
IMO switch Hatate for Vassell and Findlay for Scales and it’s given as offside other end of the pitch