Madine left 15th January, Loy joined on the 28th January hence I was correct
You're partly right, though, Madine was loaned back to Carlisle but that was in January 2014 - some 6 months after Loy had left the club. In his whole 26 year existence , Rory Loy has never played with Gary Madine. Unlucky.
Looks like a tidy signing to be honest, happy enough.