Kelly, Semple, Morrison and I hate to say it, but KVDW. All three of those are decent at Championship level, with Kelly and VDW tested at Premiership level, but none really stand out as potential key members of the team for me. Bit part players maybe, and I would like to see more of Semple, but I think we will strengthen the defence better this summer than we have done before.
Cowie is an odd one, as he undeniably has the ability and the experience, but he has not had the impact I had expected when he arrived. Yes he is now a senior member of the squad, but he has ghosted through a selection of games. Maybe played as a holding midfielder or an impact sub may be his calling next season?
McManus is a good wee player with a lot of effort, but is better out wide and cutting inside. He gets bullied by big defenders and doesn't have the composure of a Graham/McKay/Stewart to test the keeper from all angles. Think he should be seen as being another Midge to be honest