I’m sceptical that anyone who says they can’t stand playing the same teams four times actually goes to the games.
I’m by no means any sort of super-fan myself, but all I want is to go to Cappielow and hopefully see Morton play well and win, within a competitive context. The fact I may have seen the opposition in October isn’t in my thought process and I find it bizarre it would have any bearing on anyone else’s feeling about whether they wanted to go and see their team that week.
Any reconstruction to create bigger leagues solely to move away from a double-round robin would be dreadful as:
(1) the higher the stakes, the bigger the interest from fans, which obviously creates revenue and, not to be underestimated, memories.
(2) the knock-on effect is to weaken and reduce competition within every single division below that sits within the pyramid.
Ergo, smaller divisions are better and, in the absence of radical changes to levelise spending, we should be wary of any reconstruction.
I think it only needs tinkering, specifically on the hellacious Premiership playoff format, and potentially moving the SPFL’s 12-team league to the bottom tier rather than at the ‘Premiership’ level which is a misnomer when it’s our largest league.