I have a mate who is a Talbot fan, and he used to laugh at the players we signed from the juniors when Shanks and the two Rabs were in charge. He said that they weren't even good junior players.
Neil Watt was the most disappointing appointment definitely - given that he actually had done very well at Stranraer. He signed all his pals from Stranraer for a jolly old reunion and they didn't bother actually trying.
I'd also stick my neck out and say Campbell Money was worse than Roberts.
Roberts is a decent guy and was a great player for us. However, he should have never been appointed manager.