Everyone has an opinion I personally don't think anyone should be shot down until given a chance to prove himself, he's training with us, will probably play a few games as a trialist, won't be good enough and will go back to the bankies. Won't cost us anything and won't harm anyone. If he does turn out to score a few and impress aitken well good on him, he will have put in some effort to do so, unlike some we could mention that got signed anyway, Wilson, Miller, smith....etc etc