Jump to content

Dons_1988

Platinum Members
  • Posts

    22,326
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    47

Posts posted by Dons_1988

  1. 2 minutes ago, Illgresi said:

    Technically still possible to finish top 6 unless I've miscalculated horribly. Not in our hands, as would rely on a number of results going in our favour.

    Yes, mathematically it is still possible. In reality, no. 

    Does feel better having a bit of a gap over two teams and sucking Motherwell in. 

    I did think we were shit for the most part today though so can’t rest on any laurels yet. 

  2. 18 minutes ago, BFTD said:

    Clearly we really need a full, ordered list of Scotland's biggest clubs so the perennial second tier fans can have a sensible, rational discussion about not being placed higher due to their massive travelling support/their great-great-grandpa seeing them lift a trophy after making it back from The Great War.

    At the very least an independent body should be set up to establish a clear set of criteria and order of importance to measure ‘my club is bigger than yours’.

    Longer term I’d like to see a government initiative to develop a formula or balanced scorecard to settle this debate once and for all. The people deserve to know. 

  3. 1 hour ago, DukDukGoose said:

    I remember it well. The forums were disappointed. It couldn't have been more of a 'meh' type appointment for me than it was.

    24 months later I'd have let him have a go on my wife, guided him in and lit his cigarette for him afterwards.

    Yep, I remembered his st Johnstone teams and the way they played and that he paid cash money for Ricky foster and couldn’t have been more bored by the appointment. 

    10 years on folk seem to hate him so seems I was right 

  4. 10 minutes ago, lubo_blaha said:

    I’m genuinely interested to know what communication people want. 

    When things are going bad, no one really wants to hear “we weren’t at our best, stick with us, the fans were amazing” etc. 

    For the manager search, there’s nothing much more to be said until a manager is appointed. While the process is ongoing, I don’t really see what is to be gained from saying anything publicly about it.

    The openness on things like stadiums developments, ticketing, kits and merchandise etc from AB and DC was welcomed imo and it’s a shame that this has stopped. I suppose it was inevitable when you see all the roasters tagging them in posts constantly.

    I’d rather they just provided substantive information. I’m more miserable than most, so there’s a happy medium. But I always thought cormack talked too much about what he was going to do and what he wanted. That might sound wise after the fact, but fairly certain I’ll be on record on here saying it at the time. 

    The case in point was there document about style of play etc, a garbage piece of work with absolutely nothing substantive in terms of delivery. Just a fantasy wish list of things fans like to hear. 

  5. 57 minutes ago, DukDukGoose said:

    Done well to speak for 15 minutes and say nothing at all.

    sexy the simpsons GIF

    As someone who doesn’t cry about their lack of statements I do agree with you. 

    But given the bedwetting about a lot of this I get why they went with a more intimate interview instead of a statement. 

    Was mostly a big nothing though, a 2 paragraph statement could’ve provided the same level of relevant information. 

  6. 33 minutes ago, O'Kelly Isley III said:

    Well perhaps we learned nothing new because the Manager stuck too much to type in his team selection in what was after all a home friendly match.

    Dykes was chosen over Shankland, despite him toiling in a struggling QPR team, whilst Shankland had shown enough in cameos and on Friday night to justify a start.  Similarly, John McGinn has recently gone off the boil at club level so here was a chance to start Lewis Ferguson who is having a great season with Bologna.  When he finally did get on he produced energy and forward runs which had hitherto been absent.

    So an opportunity to 'learn something new' was virtually squandered when it was obvious from 25 minutes in that we were right off it.  In singling out these players above I don't think anyone emerged with credit and I hope Patterson doesn't become the lightning rod for criticism because it was shite from back to front.

    Right ok so the manager could have made some different decisions (one of which I highlighted in my original post re dykes) and things may have gone differently. 

    Sure, we’re in agreement there. But is it worth the kind of hyperbole we’re seeing here? 

    No, IMHO. 

×
×
  • Create New...