McGarci

?

https://www.edinburghnews.scotsman.com/sport/football/hearts/latest-hearts-news/i-have-not-been-manipulated-hearts-owner-ann-budge-outlines-new-sporting-director-role-and-craig-leveins-job-826636 It seems that budge want to divide the staff, every people will have less power than CL (who apparently has total football control), not bad. more people will have differents points of view each proffesional in his duties/plot, a mister in the field, head recruitment/scout for signing/selling players, head youth academy etc and over them a main manager....

I asked for something like that some months ago, I think is a great idea, develop young local players, build a sense of comunity in your city and save some money, I think there are some local guys who can stay as "team players" in league 2, like crawford https://www.dumbartonfootballclub.com/news/?mode=view&id=4189 as I said, in spain every local amateur team has is youth system in the town/village, my local team has 7 youth teams, and the village is 2800 inhabitants, moreover the first team in the regional league

maybe they havent sold, but I really think that with your budget is difficult sign better players, and impossible fight agaisnt "old firm" the coming loan players have been good enough IMO (leigh, maddison, lowe, steward), youth players like mclennan, mckenna, and others little few (ross, campbell, wright, anderson....) are in the first team, every year the best players have been sold or have gone free when their contracts expire from aberdeen to too richer teams. moreover he has signed some unknown players (with narrow budget) who have impressed like cosgrove, lewis, ferguson etc etc) obviously some sign hasnt worked, but It happens in every team.... I am now Aberdeen´s supporter but I think mcinness has gone a excellent job rebuilding your team year by year

I think you mainly havent got wingers who supply strikers.....

the situation was untenable , we play for nothing, with a terrify lack of actitude, ideas, strong, goal, attack and even soul as I said weeks ago, CL is obsolete manager now a manager who knows scottish football, save the season, freedom lot of players and promote some young jambos..... and please, forget the signing of aleatory 7 player every market

you only have to watch the team before he came, and now. moreover, youth academy players whom have developed, money etc etc tell me one manager who could go the team better than 3th

what do it happen in stirling? please a summary... I though you are fighting for rising up league one....

anyone cant understand why hopkin didnt want tumilty, moreover morton hasnt got a RB... dificult to see him at the rock after christmas

I think everybody would want fight with the old firm, but it is impossible, aberdeen has lost year by year their best players, and finally every years go to pre-europe, I am sure there isnt a manager better than mcinness for you, although the years "wear down" a manager in the same team..... It is said that the supports need "new faces" If you want we can change him for craig levein....xd

I think your weakness is the defense, mainly crentral back, the team isnt sure and the rest of the team feel that... without shaunnesey you should have signed another experience (or two) central back for playing with kerr maybe some free player could do a job, who knows scottish football, or british football at least I though you were picked hendry on loan from celtic in summer....

carswell as central back give the team other view, he is faster than the rest, so he can cover the midfield and the fulls back (tumilty and quitongo), moreover he pass the ball extremelly better than the rest..... but, is he imprescindible in midfield too?

after watching the highlights I think there are a serius problem of selfconfident, every semi-arrival to our zone is almost goal, and we fail some cleary goal.... moreover if maclean with 35 created more chances in 30minutes than the rest in all game we have a strong problem.... ok, there are key players injuried, but without them the team is enough strong to win some matches IMO although I repeat like garlic (spanish proberb) CL is old/narrow mind, and what is worse, he cant motivate the players. very worried situation ---- other day we speak about signing/loan politicy.....

HIGHLIGHTS

if you dont want neilson we can change him for levein

another useful squad player, maybe the team have 14/15 good players, the rest are going to play only if there are injuries, exclusion.... --------bennan-------- tumilty-mcgeever-neill-quitongo -------carswell-hutton mccluskey----mckee-----frizzell -------- layne--------- more. mcmillan, langan, crossan what do you think

so why he resigned him?? as I said, CL signs too much players and later doesnt use them

if celtic or rangers come for him, he will go out, nothing to do

do you think we will sign another CB without halket and souttar? or with berra, dikamona and smith is enough?

first of all, if Aberdeen finish 3th (or 4th) I think it will be an big success, it is imposible fight agaisnt the old firm, after all, do you think any other manager is going to make better than mcIness?

obviously a mix of the 2 season best players is stronger.. but I think economicly non-viable

No, I am spanish, I lived close to haymarket the year of relegation , firstly a suit man shown me tynecastle and after that I went 3 or 4 matches (I remember cup win against QotS and lost against st mirren in league). since this day I follow hearts every I can, and try to watch a match in the stadium every time I visit edinburgh. my first match I remember that ask the man who sit near me if all the players names jamie....xd (macdonald, walker, hammil)

If we looked back the time since CL comed back: after the economic problems -In championship he signed neilson (his best decision, and maybe the only...), the team prometed easily with really good signings, a strong team, but, who decided the players, CL or RN? - after promotion, a strong championship squad with some new player, the team finish in european position his first season, no doubt was a big success - after that, wrong decision by wrong decision, bad signings (and too many), neilson departure, cathro signing, more extrange and large signigns, later he came back as field manager, defensive tactics, more extrange and large signigns.... finally a exciting begining last year, when everyone though we can fight for europe, and a strange drop till know... this summer again more strange and large signigns, and bottom of the league.... He has promoted some youth jambos, some of them look decent for the team, but they has disappeared (macdonald, cochrane, morrison), instead of them we have a big team with 25 players, where some of the arent better than youth players, dont play anything and still CL is signing more (brozanic, garuccio, dikamona, wrighton, white etc etc) *** sorry for my english.....xd***

too much players injuried, but although I repeat as garlic, too much better team than manager...

RALSTON AND HENDRY from celtic... what do you think?