I think the lack of obvious leaders is a big problem. As an experienced player, Todd, on paper, made sense but not convinced he's most vocal on pitch.
Not sure of logic of thinking that being a striker means Reilly should be on pens.
Leighton Baines scored 20 out of 22 penalties he took in Premiership. By your logic, based on that 91% record, Stephen Hendrie should be taking our pens.