DaveMackay56

Penalty without a shadow of doubt . All away from body, moving towards ball to block, stops goal bound shots. Penalty in any decade never mind this one.

£6million. Some of it will line the owners pockets, some of it apparently on infrastructure. i think hibs fan in general do not understand the current financial gaps between hearts and hibs. They will need a lot more than a one of £6m which will be less than we take from Europe next season. They’d need upwards of £4m a season just to equalise hearts, and that’s hearts pre profit from hotel, sponsorship deal, and the releasing of benefactor funds for football only.

Don’t think it will be Baccus. But hearts enquired for strain last summer and were quoted about £700k. Will be surprised if we haven’t considered

It was definitely an issue in the first half 22/23. In the second half it wasn’t the problem.

wont be the last from the SPFL.

We won’t play both of them very often wouldn’t think. We were caught out in Europe 2 seasons ago with squad unable to cope with the 10 extra games.

I was talking about the games where we dropped points. At pittodire we were comfortable first half, second half Aberdeen went long and won just about every second ball. Can’t argue with the result in the end. At tynecastle Aberdeen were the better side first half though didn’t create much anything really other than the correctly disallowed goal. Second half first 15 mins were even, after the opening goal we could have had 4 or 5 and Aberdeen couldn’t have complained.

yea all fair. Still a great run of form achieved without some big players at our disposal which was my overriding point. Need to build on it

how does turning 90% make your legs and torso bigger? This aside clearly the player was trying to make himself bigger without question, in doing so he stretched his arm out and blocked a goal bound shot. it’s a penalty, the ref got it right, there was no clear and obvious mistake this VAR should not get involved and didn’t get involved. If there’s a debate to be had it the rule not the officiating yesterday which was spot on . anyway - I get the annoyance. Dundee were very good and have some of the best individuals I’ve see. Is play against this season

Fair enough

Mate you’re digging a hole here. The rules don’t say it has to be deliberate do they? thus you cannot argue that it it wasn’t deliberate so shouldn’t be a pen. Your misunderstood both the post and the rule.

There have been countless pens for far less. Why was he swivelling btw? To make himself bigger by any chance? If you watch EPL they constantly say when this happens that turning you back on the ball is the worst thing you can do, and is used to justify pens not to argue against.

cool. Maybe I misread. It’s a good song. But timing is everything

Yes of course if a player deliberately handles of course it’s a penalty. but it’s also a penalty if it’s an accident. Not being deliberate doesn’t mean it’s NOT a pen as highlighted by your bullets You’ve proved my point mate.

A song created by hearts fans for hibs. Usually used when they are going through a poor run of form. If you want to steal it fair doo but Not one to be sung at a team closer to the title race than 4th we couldn’t stop laughing at the stupidity

it doesn’t need to be deliberate, that’s not in the rules. His arm was outstretched, the ball was on target and there was a good chance it was going in and the player was in the process of turning his back. There is zero chance it would have been overturned.

Disagree. I was at Pittodrie. In the first we were easily the better side, in the second half Aberdeen went direct and we didn’t react. Tynecastle against rangers - rangers did nothing until the break away goal. Before the goal we were the better side and had the better chances. Ross county at home was a complete robbery. Should have had 2 penalties instead we received a red card for Forest. ps. I’m not arguing that we are or would be title contenders as I don’t believe that. I’m stating that our form over the past 15 games is title contending form. Which it is clearly

If we hadn’t started the season poorly we’d be in the mix. Since game week 10 we’ve taken 3 points less than rangers and 2 more than Celtic. The only points we’ve dropped have been a robbery

Was sat beind the goals and it was going in. Hand was away from the body, the height of the hand isn’t a factor. And contrary to Peter grants opinion attempts turn away strengthens the case. In respect of these rules and some of the other decisions this season that was one of the stronger cases. As regards the difference between the 2 teams. Dundee are a very good side, in McGowan, beck and Campbell they have some very very good players. However I think non hearts fans are not conscious of the sheer number of players we are missing or not starting with. Shanks aside our squad is so much better than the other sides. E.g Gordon, Atkinson, Kingsley, Halkett, Rowles, Devlin, Mackay, Boyce, Vargas, Haring, Scott Fraser, Tagawa, Denham, Tait, Pollock. There’s 12 senior players who for one reason or another didn’t start yesterday and our best 3 young players. I’f we had to choose from that list we’d still be contenders for third. That’s why we are third by a street. Not only shanks

How could our head to head have started before the point of aberdeens existence ? head to head “hearts > aberdeen” anyway. I sense we will never agree.

Straight out of ten obtuse poster handbook. lose a debate = revert to trolling. Have a good night

Rangers . Should have been about 3 down before scoring from cross Ross county. Absolutely atrocious hibs last week battered you at least as much as we did. Aberdeen are defensively very solid. And rely on Duk who I like a lot.. top player . Beyond that? ps I didn’t watch any more but given you’ve scored 13 goals away all season I’m guessing similar .

Just trying to help educate you for future debates. Thank me later

Ah that old excuse, you lucked into the greatest manager in history . Bravo but it hardly makes you something to be revered. Hibs fans like pulling arbitrary dates for measures as well. Here is an easy one. Since Aberdeen were formed. Hearts have beaten Aberdeen more than Aberdeen have beaten hearts. And generally speaking, we’ve won more points as well.

Aberdeen tried to “entertain” today that’s enough from you tonight mate. Your bar must be limbo low. I’ve watched enough slugball over the years to recognise slugball. And Aberdeen mate. Well as I said earlier was half expecting Craig Levein to reveal himself on true Aberdeen bench. anyway. I’ll be back in about 6 months. Robson won’t see Christmas take that to the bank. Once the lucky results stop you lot will be baying for blood