Here's the thing.
We've got someone who understands the club and what it takes to be successful at the club. Appreciate that guarantees nothing though.
Do we want someone who doesn't care about the club and it's just a job to them, maybe even a stepping stone to them and their ambition. Goodwin esq.
I know what I'd prefer.
As for whether he's the right man or not in terms of ability to do the job? Who knows. Picking any manager is a gamble.