Jump to content

DonnieMurdo

Gold Members
  • Posts

    80
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by DonnieMurdo

  1. 1 hour ago, Central Belt Caley said:

    If there was any doubt about Ferguson being an utter idiot then it’s resolved now

    https://www.dailyrecord.co.uk/sport/football/duncan-ferguson-blasts-rivals-downing-32611348

    Or you know, we’re just not very good and playing 5 at the back at home helped them? 

    I kind of get where he is coming from, perhaps he is trying to call them out and motivate them for the run in ?

    But ultimately, if we are indeed relegated, it will be down to ourselves and our own results over the season, not if Arbroath " down tools" for the remainder.

    Our problems have been a lot closer to home this year, (metaphorically and statistically).

  2. 28 minutes ago, SandyCromarty said:

    Then there's the twist in that however good the player is the loser tag sticks and a possible move elsewhere results in less favourable financial contracts kick in.

    Players now facing that possibility need to give things a good hard think.

    No team will willingly sign a player with the relegation/loser tag round his neck.

    Indeed.

    Off the top of my head Gilmour and Longstaff have been relegated  with Cove last season?

    As much as Gilmour had been one of our more consistent performers, consecutive relegations would certainly not be a good look on any players résumé, although I'm not sure how involved either were for Cove last year if I'm honest, so perhaps I'm being unfair.

    The manager himself may be headed for two clubs managed / two relegated - a remarkable achievement....

    Has any one else in the modern game achieved this fête so early on in their managerial career ?

     

     

  3. 7 minutes ago, TheScarf said:

    Actually we did play like that for the 10 or so games Wotherspoon played for us and the results mirrored that.

    Correct.

    I said it at the time that I was worried for us when Wotherspoon left and wasn't in anyway replaced, and so it has proved.

    The football has been diabolical since then.

    As much as he hasn't been as good as last season, Shaw at least tries to be direct and positive and I believe has been missed the last couple of games.

    We're doomed....

  4. 2 hours ago, Juanhourjoe said:

    Losing faith in Duncan a bit right now. Still think we have players who can do better, but the tactics aren't working.

    The 2 new defenders don't necessarily weaken us at the back. But bring the ball forward a little quicker. That's one positive.

    We're still lacking a creative outlet to get in behind defences. Relying on Samuel to just batter through. And neutralising Billy (our biggest goal threat by sitting deeper. He doesn't have the vision to be making the passes to break through defences. Neither does Shaw or long staff.

    Just bring in Doran or Macgregor, play the 2 strikers high up, or both.

    Not sure about Macalister yet. Didn't seem great. But give him a bit of a chance. People a bit better, can run with the ball and getting into good positions. Looked more likely to score than Samuel by the end

    The boy McAllister looked completely lost after coming on I thought , game seemed to completely pass him by.

     

    Not going to write him off by any means, but by the end of the game we were playing like what we are - a team of strangers thrown together.

    Worrying times.

  5. The use of the word "character" seems to be used increasingly these days by coaches and pundits, almost as some sort of unquantifiable trait that some players and teams either do or do not possess.

    "My team showed great character today" and such phrases seem meaningless to me, unless this indeed something that can be coached and is expected of players today??

    To quote The Wolf - " Just because you are a character, doesn't mean you have character".

  6. 28 minutes ago, Stephen Malkmus said:

    Chilokoa-Mullen played in every Euro qualifier for Scotland U21s which is a good pedigree. Savage came through the youth system at Liverpool then played with Dunc's son at Newcastle after signing for them for £250k

    I'll be honest I'd never heard of him, but someone I know who works with the Scotland  U21s speaks highly of him so fingers crossed he can bring something to the team.

  7. 14 hours ago, Central Belt Caley said:

                             Ridgers

    Kerr Carragher Ujdur Boyes Harper

                     Gilmour  Carson

                           Anderson

                 Shaw/Samuel Mckay

    Big Dunc is cooking 

    I really like Udjur I think he's been a great find, but I'd have Devine in there instead of him currently.  He's been pretty steady recently.

  8. 1 hour ago, Shadow Play said:

    There was a time when United wouldn’t be interested in a 33 year old player that St Johnstone didn’t think was worth offering a new contract to.   As it is United fans appear delighted with their signing of Wotherspoon.  

    From what I witnessed last night and the last few months, said 33 year old walks into that team.

    Granted you were missing some regulars last night I believe ?

     

    Wotherspoon will be a brilliant addition to Utd, I would expect.

  9. 10 minutes ago, RiG said:

    Sean Welsh has made the following league appearances for us since signing (including sub appearances):

    2018/19 28 games out of 36 (78% of games)
    2019/20 5 games out of 27 (18% of games)
    2020/21 21 games out of 27 (78% of games)
    2021/22 28 games out of 36 (78% of games)
    2022/23 21 games out of 36 (58% of games)
    2023/24 6 games out of 20 (30% of games)

    He did have a couple of seasons where he was relatively injury free but even those saw him miss some game time for knocks and niggles. He had a bad metatarsal injury in 2019 which saw him miss large chunks of the following season and the less said about the most recent two campaigns the better. I can see the logic in letting him move on but I am a little concerned about who we will be able to get in to replace him.

    I agree with your sentiment.

    His time with us was definitely coming to an end , but with him back to fitness and us being very much in the mire of a relegation dogfight, I might have expected him to be at least kept to the end of this season.

×
×
  • Create New...