Jump to content

Virtual Insanity

Gold Members
  • Posts

    2,022
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by Virtual Insanity

  1. I don't think Brighton are capable of playing shut up shop football, so I wouldn't expect them to try to be overly defensive in their setup against Arsenal. 

    If he doesn't start tomorrow that's surely a significant concern for anyone. 

  2. Without wanting to sit on the fence I think there is good points on both sides here.

    My personal opinion (which I will be e-mailing TJF about this weekend) is that the reaction to the PTFC Trust announcement could have been more conciliatory in tone. That said, I absolutely agree with the substance of it, again as one of the 100+ members that e-mailed in support previously. Majority elected Trustees by May 2023 is a very reasonable and achievable request and there is no legitimate reason for not doing it by the end of this season.  My preferred position remains (and I believe there could be a route to doing so now) that the share ownership is transferred to TJF as a matter of urgency. Regardless of the makeup of the Trustees, the Trust is simply not a suitable vehicle for ownership of the shares.

    I would also add that TJF's engagement has been in my opinion exemplary and, differences of opinion on occasion as to tactics aside, I have nothing but the utmost respect for everyone who has been involved in TJF in either iteration given everything they have been through and the continued enthusiasm and energy they possess.

     

     

  3. On 29/11/2022 at 23:09, DiegoDiego said:


     


    To be fair, we've never had a Scottish Cup tie competing with the World Cup on TV before.

    I'm clearly not au fait with other clubs' lowest ever Scottish Cup crowds but I would be completely stunned if any other club in Scotland at the weekend had a crowd that was almost 20% lower than theif previous ever lowest attendances. Had a quick look at Morton and Hamilton as an example and their attendances were both actually up on recent league games which makes our figures look even worse.

  4. Our crowd on Saturday was almost 20% less than our previous lowest crowd EVER in the Scottish Cup, that's completely unheard of. Here's the lineup from that previous all time low just for comparison:

    Colin Stewart

    Grant Murray

    Mark Smyth

    David Craig

    Billy Gibson

    Ricky Gillies

    Jimmy Gibson

    Darren Brady

    Sean Kilgannon

    Mark Roberts

    Stephen McConalogue.

     

    If PTFC Directors are treating such obvious warning signs about the dangers the club faces as so trivial (I refuse to listen to the remarks to be honest) then they are actively failing their responsibilities to the club.

     

  5. 3 hours ago, jagsfan57 said:

    Victor did. And are you saying TJF don’t want new members ? Some fans still need persuading to join TJF, so even although their communications and professionalism have been exemplary in the past, doesn’t mean that can be complacent.

     

    I would say complacency is not joining TJF when the future of the club is at stake. I can't understand why anyone who is remotely engaged would not be signed up at this point. 

  6. 2 hours ago, craigkillie said:


    I don't see how playing 45 (or even 90) minutes in a low key friendly is going to give Liam Kelly any sort of experience he wouldn't already have from his over 100 top flight appearances.

    I don't think it's unreasonable to think that playing for Scotland, even in a shite friendly, would be a different experience for Liam Kelly. He's playing with much better players than he's ever played with before and probably would have been under more scrutiny given our general upcoming goalkeeping issues than he's ever been at Motherwell. I think giving him game time would have been far more beneficial than another 90 for Gordon. 

  7. None of them have turned into bad players overnight, but it is clearly a significant concern ignoring the Patterson/Hickey windup shite that several of our key players are going through a tough time at their clubs. That said, this is realistically about as good a time as you could pick to have a collective shite spell. None of them have turned into poor players overnight. In Tierney's case, there are almost certainly going to be enough games for him over the next 4 months to keep him fresh and indeed given his past it might be beneficial from a Scotland point of view. I also agree that McGinn probably needs a bit of a rest. I think he's a good enough player that he'll force his way back in at Villa and hopefully in a better position. As long as these guys are involved every week in the matchday squads and getting at least some minutes then I don't think it's a huge concern. Gilmour is the one I'd most like to see getting more minutes but he's behind 2 excellent players who seem to be pretty robust. At least one of them is likely to move on in the next 6-9 months though and that will be the big test for Gilmour. He has time on his side and Scotland and Brighton can afford to be patient with him.

    Ultimately, what matters is how they play when they turn up for Scotland and none of the players listed have shown any significant cause for concern in that respect.

  8. 3 hours ago, Pie Of The Month said:

    I think the £45 is worth it just to have a pick of the better seats in the North stand on the opening day of the members sale which are all gone before any public sale.

     

    As someone who doesn't really make any away games now this is the only reason I renew and it's 100% worth it for this alone. 

  9. Muirhead and McMillan did OK first half v Queens, one poor goal conceded but think Hodson probably carries the can for that although not seen the replays. Our defence has only really gone to shit in the last 3 games once Akinola and/or Brownlie makes an appearance (although by all accounts Muirhead was having a nightmare against Aberdeen). Muirhead is a decent defender at this level when paired with a good CB like Holt but he's nowhere near good enough to carry Akinola or Brownlie. Has to be Muirhead and McMillan centre halves and Hodson RB. 

     

  10. On 23/10/2022 at 19:54, Barney Rubble said:

    Good analysis, thanks.

    However, it begs an obvious question - why hasn't Aidan Fitzpatrick taken advantage of the opportunity to cement a starting place?

    I think there's some rationale to your question but in fairness, Fitzpatrick has only started 3 of the 8 games Fuctifano listed, we've won 2 and the third was the Falkirk clusterfuck which largely rests with McCall. Continually playing Tiffoney both risks Tiffoney's fitness and prevents Fitzpatrick getting anything close to a run in the team.

    Anyway it's all moot if Holt is out for 8 weeks. Any word on Docherty?

×
×
  • Create New...