johnnydun

Apart from the fact Cove have not won their league and Stranraer have not been relegated.

You said teams deserve promotion and relegation as they stand, they don't.

But the alternative is not null and void, I just gave you 1 and Ann Budge claims the SPFL has 6 but only presented 1.

11-1 needed in the Prem. Can't see it.

But your argument is that teams currently deserve promotion and relegation. I am just putting your argument to bed.

Yes you would need to have a vote.

Not if your awarding titles.

Says who? If you can restructure to include 2 teams in another division the you can restructure to have no relegation or promotion.

Plenty more examples if you want; Man United had an 11 point lead over Arsenal with 9 to play. Arsenal won the league 97/98. Mid February 2017 St. Mirren (10th) were 12 points behind both Raith (in 8th) and Dumbarton (in 7th) with 12 games to go. St Mirren ended up above you both. Stirling Albion were 8 points off Alloa in top spot with 6 games to play in 2009-10 , tier 3, they went top with 2 games to play and won the title. Just highlighting that nobody has earned or deserves to be promoted or relegated at this stage. Yeah, I guess we just disagree.

This will need a 11-1 Premier league vote in favour. I just can't see it. What is more likely is the season is ended now, with trophies and money handed out and no relegation or promotion. Technically not null and voiding it but concluding it.

But they haven't. They have not won anything mathematically. I will give you an example, Arsenal had an 8 point lead over Man United in March 2003. Man United won the league by 5 points. A 13 point swing. You clearly have no idea of my current view. I will respond by giving you my thoughts on your current view; If Cove and United get promoted because they 'deserve' it then it leaves the league no option but to promote you and if others get relegated it would be a case of " oh dear, how sad, nevermind".

So if you admit that the haven't won their league, why should they be rewarded with promotion? (Well not Celtic obviously)

This 'deserve' argument is a complete non starter. No team 'deserves' to be relegated or promoted as no team has mathematically confirmed any place.

The East Fife Chairman kens... https://www.google.co.uk/amp/s/www.dailyrecord.co.uk/sport/football/football-news/dundees-spfl-waiting-game-strategy-21855606.amp

If Nelms changes to a Yes vote for nothing but a sweetener and benefit to our club then I will fully condemn it and seriously assess my position in ever going to Dens again while he is in charge. If Nelms changes to a Yes vote on the basis that he has been given assurances from enough members that a reconstruction will take place to benefit the others in relegation positions then fair play. If not, then he must vote No and another proposal must be put forward.

If there was a bad winter month with a few weeks of postponements, would they be in the same position?

Only if they voted no.

Does he not use his signature in the club programmes? Under his weekly statements? Is it the same?

I wouldn't be surprised that Drysdale voted without Nelms say so.

So why not vote to change those rules?

Prove it.

No, the club didn't vote at all yet.

Don't know what you're on about. He's saying he did not receive my votes anyway.

Pfft. Lies mate! I take it you have evidence I sent these?