Cptn Hooch

This'll get overturned I think

We should really be level at least between the penalty and Stephen Kelly's chance at the end...Shinnie has been brilliant today barring his penalty

It's 100% a foul...not sure it was a penalty though

No mention of Big Sexy Lee Miller yet? Disappointing. Andrew Shinnie is also a very handsome man in person. My daughter was a mascot last season and was really shy when she met him because he's "byooteeful"....the wife was less discreet and had to be torn away from him

Going by the photos posted it looks like Sangare and Penrice both trained in preparation for the weekend. The young boy Ledingham was talked up at the beginning of the season and has featured on the bench plenty but yet to see him play. With our issues in defence, I do wonder if we might see him at some point soon. With the personnel available we could go for something like Shamal Brandon Donnellan Nottingham Penrice Holt Shinnie MacKay Sangare St Kelly Anderson

I would imagine our budget constraints would have the most impact on bringing in loans from bigger sides. These players from Liverpool, West Brom will still be on much higher wages than we can afford (even if it's only a percentage we're expected to pay). I'm sure martindale would prefer a young, up and coming keeper on loan from Sheffield United or something but we've had to go for a 39 year old Mike McGovern from Hearts

Weren't the charges against him dropped?

Will there be highlights anywhere?

Positional issues are understandable but playing in a different position shouldn't impact a player's ability to make a simple 5 yard pass or his ability to control a ball

Is that the shock of the round? Not only winning but coming back from going a goal down early

At the time Jack wanted to play regular first team football and was behind an in form Nicky Devlin, James Penrice and Cristian Montano. I liked Jack as a player and was gutted to see him leave but it was the right decision

I believe he tried to lay Martindale out with a headbutt after being dropped due to his Dundee performance

Only seeing th highlights on YouTube but is there another angle for the Guthrie offside? The one on the highlights surely can't be used to determine he was definitely off.

He reminds me of Dolly Mega that we had. Capable of the ridiculously skillfull and the just plain ridiculously rubbish in the same game

Don't know who should be punted first; Nouble Devlin Martindale

Have you seen OUR defence?

Do Martindale and Nouble even come.out for the second half?

Joel fuckin Nouble

Very attacking side...hope it works.

3-4-3 possibly Shamal Notts - Ayo - Devlin Montano - Holt - Pittman - Penrice Anderson - Guthrie - Nouble

I like big Notts. For a guy of his size and age, he has a decent turn of pace. Certainly feel more confident with the defence when he's there

I read the first line and thought it was going to be the normal "Stephen Kelly not starting here is a shamble from Martindale... etc etc" but I agree with you... hopefully that means he's rested for st Johnstone which is a game we should have more of the ball

At the time he was dropped, De Lucas had been responsible for something like 60% of our goals conceded. He was dropped for a reason

Didn't deserve to lose tonight. Miovski showed the difference a proper striker can make

There's been almost identical tackles by Aberdeen players that haven't been given as fouls