Won't quote the whole post.
I agree with the sentiment but the fundamental problem is the capitalist nature of football.
The clubs, the SPFL, the SFA see us as competing in a global market, not simply growing a domestic one. That means having our top teams competing in Europe to attract investment, tv deals etc and everyone, except the fans of course, reaps the rewards.
A salary cap on the OF in particular means Scotlands days of competing in European football are over, so no one in power will sign up to it. No one. Similarly ditching leagues for a more of a lottery might see a total diddy team take our CL spot, which again, no one will sign up to it.
Your ideas are feasible if a) Scottish football operated in a bubble and b) if boards of directors owed a duty of care to the fans and not predominantly the shareholders and their investments.
The clubs have signed up to this to such an extent that a lot can't survive without tv money and the pay day that a visit from the OF brings, so they are too far down this road. 2012 was the chance to make real change, it's gone now and we're back to business as usual.