-
Posts
1,085 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Events
Store
Everything posted by ShineOnYouCrazyDiamonds
-
The released didn’t seem that big to me until I realised with loanees returning it actually only leaves four players in negotiations on top of the four signed up. I love Easton but I said before McCabe was always the priority for me (although I didn’t expect him as manager) and Frizzell was my player of the year vote so I’d be very happy for us to keep both. Not really much to argue with in terms of who has been released. Currie, Kerr, and Allan probably at the top end of the released list where it seems they could have stayed and we probably wouldn’t be up in arms if Gabby had been released but, the comings and goings (within our control) thus far seem absolutely fine. Excited to see who we bring in now that we’re getting to that stage. Best thing under Murray for me was recruitment, so it’ll be interesting to see how we get on with that now he’s away.
-
Petrie is contracted until 2025 and there’s no way we’ll compensation for anyone. Even if we would, Petrie wouldn’t leave Montrose for us since he probably has a better shot at promotion with the team he’s already been building for years that have regularly challenged the playoffs than one he’d have to rebuild from scratch. I wanted Dunfermline to go for Petrie as that would mean all the teams expected to be near the top end of our league would have new managers, but the reality is that Montrose’s stability might give them an advantage this coming season, or at least negate the disadvantage of being a part time team in what is quickly becoming a full time (at least at the top end) league.
-
As much as I laughed at McKinnon’s failure at Falkirk I’d take him if he’s fit enough to work at the moment. He’s probably one of the better options actually. And I think the last couple of seasons have made it clear that while He certainly could’ve done a better job at Falkirk, he wasn’t the only issue at the club and the failure wasn’t his alone.
-
Wasn’t Paul Ronald heavily involved in Accies’ youth coaching round around the time McCarthy and McArthur came through? I wouldn’t be filled with optimism by his appointment but I suppose that’s something. In my opinion what we need is someone with some decent experience (i.e. not his first management job) but also not a dinosaur like Jim Duffy or Yogi Hughes. Preferably someone who can come in and continue Murray’s work, rather than someone who will try to completely change everything at the club. Not sure who my preferred realistic option is yet as there are a few that seem fine but none that really jump out.
-
I’ve pretty much always backed Murray and he definitely improved us, albeit gradually, during his tenure. But I agree he got it wrong in the playoffs. Once Kerr was fit to play he should’ve been back in the team and Agnew should have dropped out with McCabe moving into midfield. It’s something a lot of us had been calling for for ages. I couldn’t believe his subs in the second leg against Queen’s Park. You might think of Simon Murray’s penalty hitting the back of the net, or even Easton’s foul in the box, as the moment that resigned us to defeat. But at 1-1 when Callum Smith was subbed off I’d basically accepted defeat. He was the last player left on the pitch I felt could score the winner for us after others had also been subbed off. His recruitment, however, was pretty much always bang on. And you can’t take away from him, despite ultimately failing to get promotion in the end, he put together the best Airdrie team and years and gave us the best football in years. That unbeaten run really was special. Good luck to him at Raith Rovers. I imagine if given time he’ll be a success.
-
I’d imagine the club will offer everyone except Pyott, Walker and Ritchie a new deal. Unsure about Cantley or McDonald as they might be kept as back ups and it’s hard to know the situation with Lyons since he’s been out all season, but recent history suggests we’ll give him another year as we did so with Scott Gallacher, Craig Thomson, and even Pyott through their injury problems. Also unsure about Gabby and Jordan Allan as the club might only be keen to keep one in order to make room for a new forward. Smith and Kouider-Aissa obviously already signed up. I’d say out of the rest there’s a danger of McCabe, Frizzell, Easton leaving for a better offer elsewhere and Kerr leaving for more game time. I’d say that gives us Currie, Fordyce, Watson, Agnew, Gallagher, Smith, Kouider-Aissa as definite members of next season’s squad and I’d expect Lyons and one of Allan or McGill to be added to that, though I’m less sure with them. We’d do really well to keep McCabe, Easton and Frizzell and I expect Easton and Frizzell to probably be off but I’m hopeful McCabe will stay. Even if we kept all three we’ll still need to bring in a lot of players to replace departing loanees, particularly in defence, and if they leave we’ll need an entirely new midfield.
-
The problem is that if Murray leave we’ll also be in transition. Hopefully Dunfermline steal Petrie to put Montrose into that category rather than ourselves. Agree on the priorities. I love Easton but imo he’s not as important as the likes of McCabe and Frizzell. Think you’re spot on about adding a bit physicality at the back while maintaining what we have making us potentially a favourite for the league.
-
Dunfermline's Next Permanent Manager
ShineOnYouCrazyDiamonds replied to Ludo*1's topic in Scottish League 1 General Chatter
I’m worried that a certain Mr Ian Murray might be an inevitability here