I thought Mackin and Lewis were too far apart at times yesterday. Mackin looks capable of winning the ball in the air but needs someone closer to him. The understanding between them wasn't there but that could come with games. On the basis of the games i've seen, a friendly against Airdrie and yesterday I don't feel in a position to say whether any of the players are shite or brilliant. They need time, as does Hartley to decide on his best 11, formation etc. I still think we need another forward player and Robson is better at left back as Brough looked out of position yesterday.