I’m very much in the camp of not getting rid of him, although I wouldn’t be gutted if he went. Every single person on this forum agreed that his signings, bar probably Wright improved us. You could now add Kinnear into that bracket. He said last summer we need more street wise players with a bit of dig and steel. He’s signed Nesbitt again, however he clearly rates him (as does his peers going by the team of the season). He knows where we need to Strengthen and I think he’ll do that again in the summer. I hope to see a fair few leave in the summer ie loan players bar Kennedy, McKay, McGuffie, Hetherington etc. Tuesday was a disgrace and I fully admit he should have changed shape when we went 3-0 down, however at least half of the goals came from players individual mistakes that no manager can compensate from. Give him until October/November and see where we are, because at worst case scenario , I don’t think we’d be far off play offs by then anyway.