Jump to content

The Rose v Musselburgh. Scottish Cup Semi Final


Dr V

Recommended Posts

  • Replies 296
  • Created
  • Last Reply

My take on things is today both teams were pretty evenly matched, 2 mistakes costing the Rose goal but you could say the same for Mussey.At this level thats going to happen.Bigger picture was man for man Musselburgh were better over the 2 legs and good luck to them in the final, apart from the number 10 who decided to try and score after a dead ball was given by the ref for an injury.Interestingly it was a last ditch tackle by a shocked rose man which in normal circumstances could have been a red was met by the ref with a glare at the centre forward. Common sense prevailed. So well done Musselburgh and I hope you win the final. 2 games with over a 1000 fans at each and no hassle, as it should be HTG

Link to comment
Share on other sites

We should keep hold of the 2 keepers, Thom, McKillen, the McLennans ,Calum Smith and Billy McAdam. The rest can go and will not be missed

We will take Batchy and Kelbie back if you don't want them

Link to comment
Share on other sites

We should keep hold of the 2 keepers, Thom, McKillen, the McLennans ,Calum Smith and Billy McAdam. The rest can go and will not be missed

2/3 of these players can't even regularly get a game.

We have 4 centre forwards and 5 centre mids all who would walk into most teams. You can only really play 4 out of the 9 in their favoured positions or as happens you play them out of position.

Without balance you will always struggle - we need to build a team and not just sign players in the same positions

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Dave it has not been a few below par performances. We have been poor for a long time and worse the attitude is shocking.

Don't disagree with that - my argument has always been that we aren't a team when you regularly have players out of position.

April and we don't know our best team or formation. We can't go 90 minutes without conceding silly goals.

The quality is there individually but not as a cohesive unit.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Good luck burgh in the final. Never mind for the East, go out and win it for yourselves!

You deserve to be there.

Ps - it wld be an added bonus to see some talbot know alls taken down a peg or two who think they will just need to turn up.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...