Jump to content

Can't see this ending well


Rugster

Recommended Posts

  • Replies 74
  • Created
  • Last Reply

I had taken it from an article that she had had all the surgery but didnt have the gender reassignment certificate yet, so was still legally male but physically and mentally female?

Sounds like a horrible cow who probably cant be all to surprised at some jail time, which should be in a female facility.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1. She has had hormonal treatment and surgery and has been living as a woman for years.

2. She is not "gender confused". She is asserting her right to be a woman. Gender dysphoria is a much earlier stage in the process.

3. Even if a prisoner were at the early stages of gender dysphoria, there should be much more effort made to accommodate them within the prison system. The likelihood of a man pretending to be a woman to go to a women's jail is astonishingly low.

4. Gender and sex are not the same. You have arbitrarily decided that genitalia are a reliable indicator of a prisoner's risk factor including within the prison system's trans community. This is plainly not the case.

5. Treating her as though she is a man based on assumptions arising out of her genitalia is transphobic.

6. There is no evidence whatsoever that birth sex is "the safest option at the present moment".

7. It's not her fault if "society is not currently set up to deal with these issues".

8. Even if that were true, existing prison guidelines are supposed to make exceptions for those at an advanced stage of transition who do not yet have a state-mandated Gender Reassignment Certificate.

So basically, you are a bigot, unless you recognise that she has a perfectly reasonable complaint here. If you want to remain a bigot that's entirely up to you, but a bigot you are.

I used that exact same argument with my mates after being found in bed in Thailand with a Women called Bert.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

8 previous convictions? Sounds like she's a bit of a c**t.

Hence the female prison. Had she been a bit of a dick, male prison for sure.

Anyway, according to that BBC article

More than 140,000 people signed petitions calling for Hudson to be moved, with supporters claiming she had been placed in danger of sexual violence.

Would this argument apply to anyone in danger of sexual violence in a male prison? Could a "prison bitch" demand a move to a female prison to avoid sexual violence?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

What about the woman prisoners she/he is now locked up with?

With the previous violence she/he has commited, any hormone therapy can't have been too successful if she/he is laying out bar managers et al.

People aren't put in men's prisons because they have high testosterone levels. Don't be a moron.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...