To be honest, and just my opinion. A big budget doesn't guarantee success. Look at my club Rossvale. There will be clubs way lower down paying more than we do. I would imagine our highest paid player gets less than Talbot's, Pollok's, Beith's etc. lowest paid player, yet we have made it to the top division and are giving a decent account of ourselves. 7 of our regular starting 11this season, were in the team that won the old first division 2 seasons ago. The reason for that is we got a group of good young players in a few seasons ago, appointed young hungry managers Gints, then Moff and now Gorms. All with fresh ideas that the team bought into. Despite plenty of interest from elsewhere with a lot more money offered, 7 starters are still there 3 seasons later.
The key to Arthurlie getting back on top is getting the recruitment right and creating an environment that makes the players want to stay, and not chase money elsewhere.