football maniac Posted April 13, 2015 Share Posted April 13, 2015 Qos: Keep: Dowie, Lyle, McShane (under contract anyway) Higgins, Atkinson, Hooper, both Smiths, Pickard, Millar, Burns, Russell, Kidd and in an ideal world Holt, Durnan, Reilly and Clark Release: Dzierzawski, Slattery, Mitchell Undecided: McKenna, Paton Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
SUPERSOUTH Posted April 13, 2015 Share Posted April 13, 2015 Qos: Keep: Dowie, Lyle, McShane (under contract anyway) Higgins, Atkinson, Hooper, both Smiths, Pickard, Millar, Burns, Russell, Kidd and in an ideal world Holt, Durnan, Reilly and Clark Release: Dzierzawski, Slattery, Mitchell Undecided: McKenna, Paton Mckenna must be offered a deal been like a new player since his comeback from injury. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
CraigFFC_ Posted April 13, 2015 Share Posted April 13, 2015 Falkirk Keep:- Peter Grant, Will Vaulks, Aaron Muirhead, Luke Leahy, Mark Kerr, Tom Tawio, Blair Alston, Craig Sibbald, John Baird, Kevin O'Hara, Botti Biabi. Get Rid/Relsease:- David Smith, Olu, Alex Cooper, Taylor Morgan. Undecided:- Jamie MacDonald, Kieran Duffie,Scott Shepherd. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Sloop John B Posted April 13, 2015 Share Posted April 13, 2015 I'd keep McKenna as he is hopefully over his injury problems and Burns can stay as he brings value as a coach but I suspect that his style of play is starting to catch up with him. Chris Mitchell looks done and he's been replaced by Dowie and Kidd. Full time personal trainer in 4 years NAP. Kevin D can also go. Paton's chocolate hamstrings are too risky to take a wage out on again. He might need another summer to get back to what he was like but we've been saying that since he came here. He doesn't seem like he fits into our style of play that well any more. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
SodjesSixteenIncher Posted April 13, 2015 Share Posted April 13, 2015 Not 100% sure who's out of contract apart from the loanees. So I'll just do it for everyone including them. Keep: Cerny, Hanlon, Forster, Fontaine, Gray, Stevenson, Robertson, Fyvie, McGeouch, Allan, Stanton, Harris, Cummings, El Alagui. Undecided: Perntreou, Watson, Boyle, Malonga, Djedje Release: Oxley, Craig, Handling. Keeping Harris would mean Boyle would almost certainly not stay. I thought Boyle was exceptional as a RWB, which was a huge surprise. If he can keep doing that I'd change my mind. Somone who could play LB and CB for competition, a proper defensive midfielder and maybe someone who could play up front or wide depending on the formation would be nice to bring in. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
palmy_cammy Posted April 14, 2015 Share Posted April 14, 2015 How anyone can be undecided about McKenna after watching the last few games is beyond me. He has been immense. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Rovers1992/1993 Posted April 14, 2015 Share Posted April 14, 2015 Raith Rovers Keep: Mcgurn, Thomson, Watson, Barr, Mckeown, Callachan, Anderson, Conroy, Vaughan, Release: Cuthbert, Scott, Fox, Elliot, Mckay( Away back to Rangers anyway - Thank f*ck) Undecided: Moon, Hill, Nade, Stewart, Laidlaw. Keep these players if there isn't better available for the same money. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
palmy_cammy Posted April 14, 2015 Share Posted April 14, 2015 Release - Dzierzawski and Mitchell. Undecided - Clark, Slattery, Paton. Keep - the rest. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Rovers_Lad Posted April 14, 2015 Share Posted April 14, 2015 raith roverskeep- mcgurn, thomson, watson,callachan, anderson,nade,vaughan,undecided: barr, hill,stewart, release-the rest along with murray Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Jan Vojáček Posted April 14, 2015 Share Posted April 14, 2015 Goalkeepers 1. Danny Rogers- (20) May 2015 (loan from Aberdeen) 19. Jamie Ewings- (30) May 2015 (Only as backup) 21. Stephen Grindlay- (32) May 201527. Josh Lumsden- (18) May 2015Defenders 26. Joe Coleman- (18) May 2015 (On loan at Kilbirnie Ladeside)4. Andy Graham- (31) May 20153. Scott Linton- (25) May 201512. Scott Taggart- (22) May 20152. David Van Zanten- (32) May 2015 (option for a further year) (Solid enough, but Taggart is better and he's spent the last few months injured)5. Lee Mair- (34) May 2015 18. Stuart Findlay- (19) May 2015 (loan from Celtic) 22. Mark Wilson- (30) May 2015 Midfielders11. Jordan Kirkpatrick- (22) May 20156. Chris Turner- (27) May 20157. Mark Gilhaney- (30) May 20158. Scott Agnew-(27) May 2015 15. Donald McCallum- (18) May 2015 25. Keir Whitefield- (17) May 2015 17. Darren Petrie- (19) May 2015 (on loan from Dundee Utd) Strikers 14. Garry Fleming- (27) May 201510. Mitch Megginson- (22) May 2015 20. Archie Campbell- (23) June 2015 (Probably not bother keeping him as his goal record is appalling. Played quite well recently though) 16. Dylan Easton- (20) May 2015 (on loan from St Johnstone) (I like him, but he doesn't suit our style of play) 9. Chris Duggan- (21) May 2015 (on loan from Partick Thistle) (Missing, any sightings then please report them to me) RED = Punt ORANGE = Meh, undecided GREEN = Keep Keeping the loan players I've chosen is very ambitious (not going to happen) Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Hawk Posted April 14, 2015 Share Posted April 14, 2015 Qos: Keep: Dowie, Lyle, McShane (under contract anyway) Higgins, Atkinson, Hooper, both Smiths, Pickard, Millar, Burns, Russell, Kidd and in an ideal world Holt, Durnan, Reilly and Clark Release: Dzierzawski, Slattery, Mitchell Undecided: McKenna, Paton Move McKenna into keep. Our problem will be, out of those we want to keep how many will we actually able to? Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Thommo90 Posted April 14, 2015 Share Posted April 14, 2015 Keep: Taggart Graham Turner Gilhaney Agnew Kirkpatrick Fleming Campbell Punt: Mair Grindlay Ewings Undecided: Van zanten Linton Wilson Megginson Of the loanees we had this year the only ones Id be happy to bring back are Kane, rogers, and findlay. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Crawford Baptie Posted April 14, 2015 Share Posted April 14, 2015 Keep: McCracken Muirhead P Grant Taiwo Kerr Vaulks Leahy Blair Baird Bowman Thomas Grant Sibbald Alston Bia Bi Get Rid: Ollie Jamie MacDonald Maybury (keep as coach) Cooper Morgan Rowan Undecided: Duffie Smith Shepherd McGeever Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Rovers_Lad Posted April 14, 2015 Share Posted April 14, 2015 I dunno if I'm missing something... but how can you be undecided on your joint top goalscorer and also want to release the other? (Conroy)... probably because its only in the last couple of months hes scored most of his goals,up until then pretty ineffective.conroy for me doesnt contribute enough in open play and although he has scored 6 have opted to keep nade and vaughan who have both also scored 6 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Muzza81 Posted April 14, 2015 Share Posted April 14, 2015 If we stay up. Keep: Brownlie Thomson (think he will go FT) Armstrong Wedderburn O'Brien Brett Toshney (think he will get a FT deal elsewhere) Robertson Unsure: Milne (under contract so he will stay but he's been poor) Hughes (same as above) Nish (under contract but will be too old) Marshall (I reckon he will command too high a fee for what he brings) Adamson (quite like Kenny but struggles at this level, would probably keep him) Bin: Miller Higgins Johnston Kane Campbell Halsman Lynas Callaghan Scullion Stewart Of the loan signings I wouldn't rush to get any of them back but Herron and Buchanan would be worth a sniff. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
sjc Posted April 14, 2015 Share Posted April 14, 2015 Hearts: Keep: GK - Alexander GK - Hamilton Def - Paterson Def - Wilson Def - Ozturk Def - McHattie Def - McGhee Mid - Gomis Mid - Pallardo Mid - Buaben Mid - Nicholson Mid - King Mid - Walker St - Sow St - Keatings St - Carrick - Give him more time as unlucky with injuries. St - Oliver - Youngster that's yet to prove his potential. Undecided: Mid - Holt - Think there's a decent player in there but may be on too much money. Mid - Robinson - Similar situation to Holt but slightly less potential. Mid - Anderson - Yet to see what he has to offer. St - El Hassnaoui - Like his workrate & willingness but not sure what position suits him. Release: GK - Gallacher - See Hamilton as a better understudy with more potential Def - McKay - Decent player but McGhee has more potential Def - Eckersley - Good player & would have kept but for his wage demands St - Zeefuik - Hard to gauge how good a player he is in this league but no thanks at £300k Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
optimistic Posted April 14, 2015 Share Posted April 14, 2015 Goalkeepers 1. Danny Rogers- (20) May 2015 (loan from Aberdeen) 19. Jamie Ewings- (30) May 2015 (Only as backup) 21. Stephen Grindlay- (32) May 2015 27. Josh Lumsden- (18) May 2015 Defenders 26. Joe Coleman- (18) May 2015 (On loan at Kilbirnie Ladeside) 4. Andy Graham- (31) May 2015 3. Scott Linton- (25) May 2015 12. Scott Taggart- (22) May 2015 2. David Van Zanten- (32) May 2015 (option for a further year) (Solid enough, but Taggart is better and he's spent the last few months injured) 5. Lee Mair- (34) May 2015 18. Stuart Findlay- (19) May 2015 (loan from Celtic) 22. Mark Wilson- (30) May 2015 Midfielders 11. Jordan Kirkpatrick- (22) May 2015 6. Chris Turner- (27) May 2015 7. Mark Gilhaney- (30) May 2015 8. Scott Agnew-(27) May 2015 15. Donald McCallum- (18) May 2015 25. Keir Whitefield- (17) May 2015 17. Darren Petrie- (19) May 2015 (on loan from Dundee Utd) Strikers 14. Garry Fleming- (27) May 2015 10. Mitch Megginson- (22) May 2015 20. Archie Campbell- (23) June 2015 (Probably not bother keeping him as his goal record is appalling. Played quite well recently though) 16. Dylan Easton- (20) May 2015 (on loan from St Johnstone) (I like him, but he doesn't suit our style of play) 9. Chris Duggan- (21) May 2015 (on loan from Partick Thistle) (Missing, any sightings then please report them to me) RED = Punt ORANGE = Meh, undecided GREEN = Keep Keeping the loan players I've chosen is very ambitious (not going to happen) I'd keep archie, he did have a horrendous injury, and is getting better all the time. Mark Wilson will definitely be better if he stays clear of injuries. Good experience at the back, and will benefit from a full pre-season, otherwise I totally agree with you, and if findlay doesn't come back, Coleman deserves his chance, Taggart been probably best summer signing, but van Zanten did make right back his position, 50/50 who stays out of those two Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Thommo90 Posted April 14, 2015 Share Posted April 14, 2015 I'd keep archie, he did have a horrendous injury, and is getting better all the time. Mark Wilson will definitely be better if he stays clear of injuries. Good experience at the back, and will benefit from a full pre-season, otherwise I totally agree with you, and if findlay doesn't come back, Coleman deserves his chance, Taggart been probably best summer signing, but van Zanten did make right back his position, 50/50 who stays out of those two Id also keep archie, sonsteam said his goal record isn't great which is true, but at the end of the day how many starts has he had up front? Also when he gets subbed on its 9/10 times to play wide. Plus the only players who have scored more than him are aggy and fleming who both start far more games than him. He's been playing better but obviously needs someone to help him up top, don't think that player is fleming, he's better in midfield. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
The_Pit_Owns Posted April 14, 2015 Share Posted April 14, 2015 If we stay up. Keep: Brownlie Thomson (think he will go FT) Armstrong Wedderburn O'Brien Brett Toshney (think he will get a FT deal elsewhere) Robertson Unsure: Milne (under contract so he will stay but he's been poor) Hughes (same as above) Nish (under contract but will be too old) Marshall (I reckon he will command too high a fee for what he brings) Adamson (quite like Kenny but struggles at this level, would probably keep him) Bin: Miller Higgins Johnston Kane Campbell Halsman Lynas Callaghan Scullion Stewart Of the loan signings I wouldn't rush to get any of them back but Herron and Buchanan would be worth a sniff. I'd agree with most of that. I'd keep Miller though - not a first team starter but can play everywhere so good cover. Hearts will surely release Buchanan so would be worth a punt if he's on low wages - see how he develops. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Rovers1992/1993 Posted April 14, 2015 Share Posted April 14, 2015 probably because its only in the last couple of months hes scored most of his goals,up until then pretty ineffective.conroy for me doesnt contribute enough in open play and although he has scored 6 have opted to keep nade and vaughan who have both also scored 6 Both Stewart and Conroy have 9 goals each in all competitions.. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.