This'll be a long post...
Can't be arsed trawling for my own posts, easier when you're showing up someone else.
MacLean was called shite and derided for constantly missing one on ones, something along the lines of "he'll never score more than five in a season"/"isn't a penalty box striker"
Murray Davidson was too bothered with getting in the box to cope with being a midfielder at this level.
Chris Millar called shite because he couldn't pick a pass/score goals/tackle or contribute at all, although that was in his right wing days.
Mannus was too slow to go down, Easton was too fat and immobile to be a decent left back.
Sandaza was too slow to be any use. O'Halloran was too thick to make it at this level, "be aswell with Forrest gump"
Obviously completely ripped into Fisher and Tanser early doors, both "weak timid pish" players.
Theres probably more, that's just what I can remember from memory. I think I've ended up slating most signings