Here's my tuppence. I'm ignoring contract length, and going on a pure keep/punt basis:
Cuthbert - Definite keep. He's no Davie McGurn, but then nobody is. As good a goalkeeper as we'll get at this level, the kind of player who could be offered a three year deal without any real worries.
Thomson - Maybe a controversial one, but I'd be having a real think about it. I'm not convinced there aren't better right backs out there. If we released him, would any other full time clubs be queuing up to take him on? I'm not sure. Wouldn't be at all upset to see him kept on, but I think he's on a shooglier peg than most club captains. At the very least, needs some competition next season.
McHattie - I'd keep him. Again, needs competition/cover, but he's been fine. Would rather focus energy elsewhere when it comes to replacements.
Callachan - Huge question mark. Willing to keep him on but he needs to decide what his game is. Clue: It's not shooting from 30 yards.
M'Voto - I'd keep him like Stevo keeps goal. Desperately.
Benedictus - He's good when he's not at left back. Definitely the better half of the Bene/Toshney partnership.
Johnston - Not for me, Clive.
Robertson - Plays less football than Douglas Bader. Didn't particularly impress me last season.
Stewart - Happy to keep him, he's handy to have around the squad, but would any other team aiming for the play-offs take him? I'm not sure.
Vaughan - Plays for Dumbarton, what a lark. Should still play for us, hope he will next season.
B. Barr - One of the few players who has, in flashes, shown the potential to challenge M'Voto for player of the year. A definite keep.
Matthews - I'm not on the hype bus with this one, sorry. More than willing to keep him on and keep giving him chances, it's the only way for a club like ours, but I can't see that he's offering anything particularly special. At best, he doesn't look out of place.
Davidson - Willing to admit I'm in the minority, but I love the big fella. I'd keep him around doing whatever needs done. I'd like to see him replace Drysdale, actually.
Osei - Hardly seen anything of him. Following him on Twitter has taught me what a "peng ting" is though, so there's that.
Coustrain - Jo-ell. Superman's long lost Irish cousin. Looks like a real prospect in the rare occasion he's allowed to kick a fucking football for us.
Lennox - Kept a clean sheet against Dunfermline despite being unable to move for the majority of the match. Had his face kicked in. He's Australian? I know nothing else about him. Utter waste of our only over 21 loan, not that that's his fault.
Roberts - I don't think he's quite as bad as some are making out, but he's also not very good. Don't expect to see him after the summer.
Skacel - Hahaha.
McManus - Less confidence than a slack bladdered pensioner with hayfever. Looks more likely to cause a fight with a team-mate or a supporter than to actually score a goal. He'll be returned to Fleetwood where he'll promptly be released, and will return to League One in Scotland and bang in 20 before once again failing in the Championship.
Thompson - Mind that goal he scored at Tannadice? Halcyon days. Don't expect to see him again.
Brennan - The fifth best goalkeeper to have played for us this season. Won't play full-time football after this season.
Penksa - bae
Hardie - Will probably be released by Rangers. Would happily take him back, he's clearly got talent.
C Barr - I really like him. If we'd had him fit all season, I don't think we'd be in quite such a shite position. Forever a gamble on fitness, but I'd be willing to give him another shot.