Norrie82

No I just feel given the team Robinson has built around Gogic it would be a huge loss if he left. That said he is the one player in the team who deserves to go and make some money. I’m not saying we should bankrupt ourselves but I’d be offering him our very best deal. You and a couple of others suggested it would be silly to go overboard which I agree but i felt you didn’t think he was as good As some said. I’d say he’s came roaring back onto form since then and seeing as he’s played every game this year I’d say he’s almost always a 7/8 out of ten and we need to try and keep him. I imagine the fact that Dundee United are a bigger club with bigger pockets could be a potential for him but I’d hope he went abroad as to see him play against us would be quite painful. Anyhow if he goes then I’m sure we’d all wish him the v best his commitment and never say die attitude have been a pleasure to watch and he epitomises everything our manager wants us to be

What about Gogic- unbelievable how good he’s been these past few games. To think some on here a fortnight ago said they’d not be bothered if we offered Gogic a better deal or not. We will offer him our top wage of that I’m sure and whilst it won’t come close he deserves to make a few bob . Our team has been built around him and he will be a huge loss.

I think we need to wait with James Scott he’s barely played and it’ll take time. Lewis Jamieson is a funny one as he at times looks dangerous but seldom produces . Again maybe game time is the issue

I have not seen anything from Jamieson yet. I understand he is still relatively young but there’s not enough coming from him. Scott too I’m hoping he will find something but early indications are he’s going to need to up his game . Agree with Gk good goalie overall but at big moments has been prone to one

I thought Dundee were quite impressive tonight. We are going to need to be at our best to hold onto fifth

No but if you don’t offer the money he will go to a rival perhaps. I’d imagine that one of our proven top performers week in week out should be entitled to think with his efforts he deserves a decent deal

Mental mate - Robinson moved him from midfield to defence and has built the side around him pretty much - I’d say it’s safe the manager would like to keep him. He’s achieved another top six finish and it seems we shouldn’t be rewarding the players ? I get it’s prob tight at times money wise but you can kiss goodbye to top six finishes if we are not able to give players a decent reward for their outstanding efforts. Not so long ago we were perennial bottom feeders

Someone tell me who’s been better than Gogic in defence this year or actually in any position. Who’s consistently performed better than him?

The manager has built the team around Gogic let’s not start putting the guy down. Yes he’s had a couple of bad games but he’s been brilliant for us and without him I’d say we’d have lost a lot more - aggressive and fast he’s a success for sure

Gogic would be a massive loss I’d rather he stayed than anyone else

Well done to our guys for outperforming our budget. Undoubtedly the best time to be a saint in my lifetime

Tordason I have to say that I was genuinely asking a question about are they funded by someone that’s allowed their manager more wiggle room in the transfer market. As a saints fan of 37 years home and away I can assure you I’m delighted at what Stephen Robinson has done for our club. I also think that your language is poor as I’m sure like my son who’s in primary there will be others reading these pages. It was simply a question no nonsense unlike your response mate

Saints are going really well. Just wondering what folks think about Kilmarnock? Are they paying much more than we do and is this the reason they have went beyond us this season - I always felt we paid simelar wages when in Top league ?

Really poor second half total collapse. I listened to Mcinnes and he demands Kilmarnock are too six and he sounds like he’s pushing them on. We always seem to be hopeful as if you know we’re not normally very good and maybe we will do it . Anyhow this today was unbelievable and it will take some time to get over

Couldn’t agree more. Gogic outstanding . Jamieson does nothing for me. Cuts back constantly and defensively he’s not strong enough. Best coming off the bench late on maybe

Magnificent today I’ve never seen such a dominant away performance in the top flight from us. Gogic is our best by. Country Mike need him tied down

I think we might have

Yes our strikers are not going to score goals and there lies the problem.

What’s a little rich is some Kilmarnock fans tweeting about their superiority. I’m not sure they’re a better team but they do have momentum and confidence at present- the pitch undoubtedly helps them

It’s clear that if Van Veen is fit he will be a real help to Kilmarnock. It kind of frustrates me that Kilmarnock appear to be set for top 6 despite having had a major rebuild in summer following then surviving last season. Mcinnes talks about them being top six acting like a top six club and we need to match this. We seem to be hopeful more than anything and if I’m honest we look like a team that is as good as Killie but I am not convinced we have the goals in us.

Yes the goals win games and we have strikers who are all decent but don’t really score

Yes the goals win games and we have strikers who are all decent but don’t really score

Yes but will he score goals ? I genuinely think we have good players but not goals in the team and I’d be shocked if we score 10 between the strikers between now and May

Id say he’d benefit from a loan as he might get game time and score a few goals. At present he will possibly be in and out of our team and on Saturday he was not able to influence the game. Some consistent games will help him come back better

He’d still score more than anyone we have even if he was half fit