No one has said that, the poster quoted what he was answering to. I think smacking has a time and place. Obviously smacking a kid with autism is wrong and you can add to that numerous other situations. No one has said, kid does something bad = A good scud. To answer your previous question about smacking outside, maybe perhaps, some parents don't want to cause embarrassment to the child and themselves. I've never raised my voice at my son in a busy supermarket for example for that reason. I have taken him to a quiet bit or outside but never in a busy place. Back in the house - Totally different, you don't have to. If folk want to shout at their kids, while others look on, fine it's their choice. It's not mine.