I don’t think many would deny that he’s been shite but he’s far from the only one. I’d say Robertson, McGinn and McGregor to name 3 have all been incredibly disappointing the past few games - yet it’s quite clear they’re still some of our best options.
The problem we have is finding an 11 that play well together in a system that suits them (and trying to get them a bit of confidence). I’m reluctant to write off any individuals as not good enough based on what we’ve seen the past year.