Sevco vs Dundee Hibernian

[kingjoey]

1 hour ago, AJF said:

In fairness, the handball rule is crystal clear in terms of a goal being scored after an attacker uses his arm. Deliberate or not, if it leads to a goal it is to be disallowed.

The Goldson one was not deliberate so could only be penalised if you consider the position of his arm to be making himself unnaturally bigger. I don’t think an arm hanging by your side could really be described as that.

His arm wasn’t “hanging by his side”.

[kingjoey]

30 minutes ago, wastecoatwilly said:

Yip, Allan Muir sees the ball hitting Charles-Cook arm and points to the corner flag, he knew sevco were shite today and gave them a helping hand.
Some fans call it unconscious bias.

Some fans call that paranoia.

[Snifter Pee Rot]

37 minutes ago, wastecoatwilly said:

Yip, Allan Muir sees the ball hitting Charles-Cook arm and points to the corner flag, he knew sevco were shite today and gave them a helping hand.
Some fans call it unconscious bias.

I will never forget him watching a Falkirk player at Easter Road rolling the ball away with a hand on the deck in their box and ignoring it in 2016. Just a play off game that we lost 3-2. Doesn't like the green and white for definite.

[kingjoey]

I’ve just seen today’s penalty incident, and like last week’s Goldson handball, that is a nailed on penalty.

[Thenorthernlight]

9 minutes ago, kingjoey said:

I’ve just seen today’s penalty incident, and like last week’s Goldson handball, that is a nailed on penalty.

Idiocy from the defender. 
Brother Muir was right to give it. 

[Jamie_B]

25 minutes ago, kingjoey said:

I’ve just seen today’s penalty incident, and like last week’s Goldson handball, that is a nailed on penalty.

Same here - it’s an absolute nailed on stonewaller. Only the paranoid/delusional will claim that as some kind of conspiracy….

[Gibby82]

Team bus bricked after the game by the Undead. Scum. Sub-human scum. 

[wastecoatwilly]

58 minutes ago, kingjoey said:

Some fans call that paranoia.

3 days between the 2 two decisions with the same referee,one was giving one was not.
This is the type of thing you would hope VAR would be consistent on because we know the refs are not after today. 

[bennett]

15 minutes ago, wastecoatwilly said:

3 days between the 2 two decisions with the same referee,one was giving one was not.
This is the type of thing you would hope VAR would be consistent on because we know the refs are not after today. 

 

celtic can always write to the SFA about it. 

[Pull My Strings]

15 minutes ago, wastecoatwilly said:

3 days between the 2 two decisions with the same referee,one was giving one was not.
This is the type of thing you would hope VAR would be consistent on because we know the refs are not after today. 

FFS man, it was a penalty. Nobody associated with United is complaining and, in any event, Muir wasn't going to give it until his linesman intervened. Take your tiny little feuds elsewhere. 

[A_Veitch]

Just seen Dundee United team. How many players need to have covid in Scotland for a game to be called off? 

[BigBo10]

Just seen Dundee United team. How many players need to have covid in Scotland for a game to be called off? 

I believe if you’ve 13 fit players and a keeper over 18 you have to fulfil the fixture.

[BigBo10]

3 days between the 2 two decisions with the same referee,one was giving one was not.
This is the type of thing you would hope VAR would be consistent on because we know the refs are not after today. 

You do realise that except in cases of offside VAR is also down to the subjective decision of a, in our case, Scottish referee?

[wastecoatwilly]

19 minutes ago, Pull My Strings said:

FFS man, it was a penalty. Nobody associated with United is complaining and, in any event, Muir wasn't going to give it until his linesman intervened. Take your tiny little feuds elsewhere. 

I never said it wasn't a pen M8.
I'm posting about the decision making made by the same referee within 3 days.

[Loonytoons]

I never said it wasn't a pen M8.
I'm posting about the decision making made by the same referee within 3 days.

The same ref gave neither. The assistant ref called that one today. This has already been posted.

[wastecoatwilly]

3 minutes ago, Loonytoons said:

4 minutes ago, wastecoatwilly said:

I never said it wasn't a pen M8.
I'm posting about the decision making made by the same referee within 3 days.

The same ref gave neither. The assistant ref called that one today. This has already been posted.

You do know who points to the spot M8?

[Loonytoons]

You do know who points to the spot M8?

You do know why they're called assistant referees M7

[Pull My Strings]

14 minutes ago, wastecoatwilly said:

I never said it wasn't a pen M8.
I'm posting about the decision making made by the same referee within 3 days.

You're snuffling around in excrement hoping to come up with a tasty morsel to feed your nonsense. That distasteful lot get treated exactly the same as your distasteful lot. It's the rest of the country that should be casting aspersions.

[DA Baracus]

23 minutes ago, wastecoatwilly said:

I never said it wasn't a pen M8.
I'm posting about the decision making made by the same referee within 3 days.

If it wasn't a penalty are you then posting to praise the official(s)?

[wastecoatwilly]

5 minutes ago, Pull My Strings said:

You're snuffling around in excrement hoping to come up with a tasty morsel to feed your nonsense. That distasteful lot get treated exactly the same as your distasteful lot. It's the rest of the country that should be casting aspersions.

Just the facts M8,same referee different outcome,I agree every decision is made on it's own merits plus we don't want referee's to become robots but we want consistency.
Between the Goldson one Charles-cook one and this one with Var in place I would expect them all to be given but we are still left with this shite being served up in our game.