To be honest John McGinn is arguably just a big a talent, and he's proven himself over a few SPL seasons now. As much as May looks outstanding, and his performance against ICT was one of the best individual performances I've ever seen in the flesh, its important we don't get too carried away. Keigan Parker scored 10 goals before December in the SPL at the age of 18, and then didn't score again all season and is now rotting in the Junior leagues. May has more talent and seems to be more mature, but I think we have to be careful not to expect too much from him too soon. He's been deadly for two years now, he'll hit a slump eventually