Except what you’ve basically said is one third very good signings that have become key first team players, one third that have contributed to the team but are not world beaters and one third write offs. For a club at our level in the markets we operate in that doesn’t seem too bad a record to me? Additionally, in your original post you admitted the club is hampered by a flawed scouting network. Recent windows have been markedly poorer and he needs to accept responsibility for that but as I originally said, the hyperbole needs toned down a bit. ETA - there’s also some on the bad list I would challenge. For example, Neil Alexander wasn’t a bad signing as such, in fact that’s an excellent back up keeper to have, joe Lewis was just terrific.