Dundee V Hearts

[ScottyDee1893]

Not suggesting he was the best by any means but Cammy Fraser almost won us promotion single handedly after joining from the Jambos

[Insert Amusing Pseudonym]

We've had some excellent players from Dundee, Stevie Frail was another very good player.

[johnnydun]

This is all oddly very friendly and sensible chat. 

It's making me uneasy.

[Tony Wonder]

Made me sick that John Robertson wore a Dundee top tbqhwy.

[VincentGuerin]

Mind the Henry Smith League Cup game (95?).  Fucking hell.

In hindsight, probably an important step forward in the development of the team under JJ. Didn't seem it at the time.

[Bigmouth Strikes Again]

50 minutes ago, Tony Wonder said:

Made me sick that John Robertson wore a Dundee top tbqhwy.

Think he feels the same, got booed before he even came on.

[The Master]

Disappointing lack of Christophe Berra mentions in this thread, tbh. 

[MazzyStar]

8 hours ago, VincentGuerin said:

Jim Hamilton was magnificent for Hearts.

Under-appreciated, imo.

Not a patch on Jack Hamilton. 

[johnnydun]

1 hour ago, Tony Wonder said:

Made me sick that John Robertson wore a Dundee top tbqhwy.

Me too.

[RossBFaeDundee]

8 minutes ago, The Master said:

Disappointing lack of Christophe Berra mentions in this thread, tbh. 

The best No. 7 we ever had 

[Fifespud]

So we give you Jim Hamilton, Neil McCann, Stevie Frail and Tosh McKinlay - and you give us Flapjack?

Set of Cuntos if you ask me. 

[JamieThomas]

9 hours ago, DeeTillEhDeh said:

 

I always make fun of the Albert Kidd guys for being 60, but 2 things:

I'm told Gordon Smith was that good that nobody who saw him play cared about his club, but more importantly that he ran the Right Wing pub out in a strange area of Edinburgh to a tee.  It's demolished now likes.

[Liam899]

Colin Cameron, Callum Elliot as well! How good was Cameron in his pomp at hearts. 

[hk blues]

Going back a bit, Alan Gordon albeit via Utd and Hibs.

I wonder how many players have played for both Dundee and both Edinburgh clubs? Is Alan Gordon unique in this? 

[Wee jeemie]

12 hours ago, Tony Wonder said:

Made me sick that John Robertson wore a Dundee top tbqhwy.

And me detested the little shit 

[Tony Wonder]

13 hours ago, Fifespud said:

So we give you Jim Hamilton, Neil McCann, Stevie Frail and Tosh McKinlay - and you give us Flapjack?

Set of Cuntos if you ask me. 

Don't forget we gave you a lend of David Witteveen.

[SweeperDee]

22 hours ago, DeeTillEhDeh said:

 

I’ve had the honor of being told I look like this legend in question on more than one occasion whilst having a directors box season ticket years ago. Probably the best compliment I’ve ever received.

[Alberto Spencer]

Willie Jamieson was a part-timer with Dundee and working as a barman in Derby's Pub in Gorgie (now The Laich) which was run by Jackie Macnamara (Snr) & Ralphie Callachan when I played against the pub for another pub on Saughton 's plastic pitch. I'd always thought Willie was gash but he dominated the game scoring a hat trick (the other two ex pros were quite good too). I had more respect for him after that.

Even more respect when he scored that 30 yarder in the last minute against Celtic for Hearts in a 1-1 draw. It certainly seemed to upset Gerry McNee the TV commentator! Willie missed the vital penalty in that weird League Cup 4-4 game at Dens when Henry Smith took (and missed) a penalty referenced in a post above.  

[Ludo*1]

16 hours ago, Tony Wonder said:

Made me sick that John Robertson wore a Dundee top tbqhwy.

Pretty sure he called Dundee fans the 'worst in the world' whilst he was playing for us. Probably because we booed him onto the pitch.

[Ludo*1]

The summer where we allegedly paid a 6 figure fee for Jack Hamilton and Hearts paid a fee for Craig Wighton is probably one of the worst bits of business we made in at least a decade and Hearts made that summer respectively.