Motherwell FC - A Thread For All Seasons

[joewarkfanclub]

An experienced player like Snodgrass who has Premiership quality could be a very useful addition to this squad. Not for a minute comparing him to Cooper, but its the kind of signing that can have impact beyond his current ability. It can raise standards and provide a leadership in the dressing room that we appear to have been missing.

Edited August 18, 2022 by joewarkfanclub

[capt_oats]

Here's Greg Marshall's profile of McKinstry.

As for Snodgrass, the fact that no one's put their name to the story means I'm entirely with the sceptical crowd.

That said, Hammell's implied that we need known quantities and Snodgrass is certainly that. He also plays in areas that we need improving.

I mean, I'm all for it in principle - it's just difficult to see it as anything other than an agent flying a kite at the moment.

Edited August 18, 2022 by capt_oats

[thisGRAEME]

I'd be bang up for Snodgrass, as he'd comfortably replace the "goes down like a shite deckchair" shithousery we've been missing since Watt left.

[Desp]

If Snodgrass is looking to make as much money as he can from his last year or two in the game, he's not signing for Motherwell.

If he wants to come back up the road, close to home, playing regular football and perhaps have a pathway to do his badges/start a coaching career, we might have a shout.  

I can certainly believe Hammell, or someone within the club, might have reached out and asked him if he fancied it.  Whether that leads to something, I'm a bit doubtful.  Maybe he pissed himself laughing at the thought of playing for £1500 a week.

Don't want to go all Si Ferry here, but he'd be a great addition to the dressing room.

['WellDel]

I'm nowhere near itk, but I did hear a rumour at the start of the week that Snodgrass' name had been heard mentioned around the corridors of the club. Definitely think there's something in it, whether that's been a tentative enquiry or something more concrete, I don't know.

Despite his lack of game time recently, I'd be very much in the yes camp. Good pro, good character and, for our level, more than a bit of a pler.

[Handsome_Devil]

33 minutes ago, Desp said:

I can certainly believe Hammell, or someone within the club, might have reached out and asked him if he fancied it.  Whether that leads to something, I'm a bit doubtful.  Maybe he pissed himself laughing at the thought of playing for £1500 a week.

Perhaps it's just because I've never been a millionaire superstar footballer but the notion of getting to that stage of your career and making your decision based on money just seem preposterous to me. Of course he might have pissed it all away and needs to urgently cram what he can get in the last couple of years into but otherwise, what's the point? Snodgrass will probably have pocketed about 10 million quid netto from his time in England. End your career somewhere you're happy playing, or where your family want to be, or that offers you a path into coaching if that's what you want, or decide based on a dozen other reasons. But seeing out your career on the basis of even tens of thousands more per year, when you're already more than set for life, just seems rather sad.

[boozyBJ]

Similar feel to this as there was to the Steve Davis story a few weeks back. 

[Swello]

Because of players like Russell, Cooper & Coyne were kicking about in the earlier years of me going to the football, I'm still an absolute sucker for top level players having a last day in the sun at a club like ours, so I'd be a massive yes to Snodgrass (and no amount of Brian McLairs or Ross McCormacks will change me).

[capt_oats]

55 minutes ago, boozyBJ said:

Similar feel to this as there was to the Steve Davis story a few weeks back. 

Aye, my feeling is similar to @Desp's post above - like the Davis story I can absolutely see a scenario where we've maybe sounded him out and asked a question. Whether or not it's anything more than that who knows?

I didn't hear precisely what he said but I suppose the fact that Hammell apparently suggested that he'd hoped to have a couple of players signed when he was talking pre-match on Sportsound means there's a chance Snodgrass is/was one of those players.

Fwiw, Snodgrass played 1096 minutes for WBA/Luton last season (actually fewer as 116 of the minutes listed below were in the u23 league). To put that in context it's less than Ojala managed for us.

I've no idea if that was down to injury or whatever but it's a fair assumption to make that he'd get significantly more game time with us than he (probably) would at another club at Championship level.

Edited August 18, 2022 by capt_oats

[RostokMcSpoons]

"Aye, so Motherwell's that way is it?"

 

I'm a bit concerned he's The Man Whose Head Expanded in that photo though, he looks like he's been poorly photoshopped   
Anyway, absolutely alongside @Swello on this one, add me to the "yes please" list... 

[For Your Pies Only]

15 minutes ago, capt_oats said:

Fwiw, Snodgrass played 1096 minutes for Luton last season (actually fewer as 116 of the minutes listed below were in the Reserves). To put that in context it's fewer than Ojala managed for us.

I've no idea if that was down to injury or whatever but it's a fair assumption to make that he'd get significantly more game time with us than he (probably) would at another club at Championship level.

Snodgrass was only at Luton for half the season - signed Jan/Feb. So he had a decent amount of playing time factoring that in

[Neil86]

13 minutes ago, capt_oats said:

Aye, my feeling is similar to @Desp's post above - like the Davis story I can absolutely see a scenario where we've maybe sounded him out and asked a question. Whether or not it's anything more than that who knows?

I didn't hear precisely what he said but I suppose the fact that Hammell apparently suggested that he'd hoped to have a couple of players signed when he was talking pre-match on Sportsound means there's a chance Snodgrass is/was one of those players.

Fwiw, Snodgrass played 1096 minutes for Luton last season (actually fewer as 116 of the minutes listed below were in the u23 league). To put that in context it's less than Ojala managed for us.

I've no idea if that was down to injury or whatever but it's a fair assumption to make that he'd get significantly more game time with us than he (probably) would at another club at Championship level.

fwiw, he did only sign for them on the 25th Feb, so 14 appearances is actually not bad.

I would be right into him coming on board, lots of experience, and the #content would be second to none.

[Handsome_Devil]

2 minutes ago, Neil86 said:

I would be right into him coming on board, lots of experience, and the #content would be second to none.

Given the undoubted power of the media team and the absolute insistence on following the five-year plan for the #content calendar to the letter, signing players based on their social media contribution seems an alarmingly plausible next step!

[JamesP_81]

I'm a +1 vote for Snodgrass . When's the cutoff for casting our votes to get him included for Saturday?( that's how it works here right ?!) . 

[capt_oats]

1 hour ago, Neil86 said:

fwiw, he did only sign for them on the 25th Feb, so 14 appearances is actually not bad.

I would be right into him coming on board, lots of experience, and the #content would be second to none.

Ah, sorry. I stand corrected.

I assumed he'd been at Luton all last season but looking at the page the minutes he played (or didn't) in the first half of the season were with West Brom - Edited my post to reflect that.

That table I posted is cumulative minutes played all season.

Here's his first half of the season with WBA - which I suppose supports the argument that he might find game time limited at another Championship club.

Edited August 18, 2022 by capt_oats

[Neil86]

Just realised Grimmy is still without a club, hopefully he gets something sorted soon.

[Kapowzer]

2 hours ago, capt_oats said:

I mean, I'm all for it in principle - it's just difficult to see it as anything other than an agent flying a kite at the moment.

100% kite flying. I do think he’s been spoken to, I think we’d be a consideration if there’s a beyond playing role.

But his character and level he’s played at I’d say it’s an almost given he would be a good value pundit maybe TV is where he’s destined.

We also seem to have been used a few times this season by agents to shore up or radar ping a manager/player.

2 hours ago, Desp said:

Don't want to go all Si Ferry here, but he'd be a great addition to the dressing room.

As long as you don’t enable a roaster, gone baggy trackie bottoms, nae socks and massive gutties.

2 hours ago, thisGRAEME said:

I'd be bang up for Snodgrass, as he'd comfortably replace the "goes down like a shite deckchair" shithousery we've been missing since Watt left.

Slattery: “….. Ahem!”

[Luke92]

Would take Snodgrass even with the injury record.

I am getting Steven Davies type feels from this though. I'd be surprised if we see it happen

[Neil86]

see with the Davis thing, was it not only the Sun that ran with the report, there seems to be quite a few running with it, BBC, STV etc.

 

[capt_oats]

3 minutes ago, Neil86 said:

see with the Davis thing, was it not only the Sun that ran with the report, there seems to be quite a few running with it, BBC, STV etc.

Nah, there were a few outlets. No BBC or STV mind you.

Edited August 18, 2022 by capt_oats