I dont hate Goodwin - and in an ideal (lets call it amatuer) world, all players would stay on their feet even when thugs take their legs.
But he is wrong about this issue. Did you hear the ex pros pissing themselves laughing at his suggestion that players shouldnt go down in the box earlier?
Did you hear David Templeton on OtB earlier today? He pointed out that no professional will turn down the chance to win a penalty because, Duh, its their job to win matches and points.
There is also a world of difference between going down when you feel the contact - like Murphy and Erwin did, and throwing yourself to the ground when there has been no contact at all - which is basically what you and Goodwin are suggesting Murphy did.
Goodwin also commented on Murphys pen v Aberdeen saying he cheated, which was analysed by 3 people on Sportscene and every single one said it was a penalty. Perhaps they were also in the wrong, like me?
And to reiterate, I like Goodwin, but dont agree with his stance here.