Jump to content

Rugby Union


kiwififer

Recommended Posts

rest of draw 

 

Pool A

New Zealand

France

Italy

Americas 1

Africa 1

Pool B

South Africa

Ireland

Scotland

Asia / Pacific 1

Europe 2

Pool C

Wales

Australia

Fiji

Europe 1

Final Qualifier Winner

Pool D

England

Japan

Argentina

Oceania 1

Americas 2

Link to comment
Share on other sites

11 minutes ago, peasy23 said:
39 minutes ago, ajwffc said:
so pool B for us 
South Africa (shit)
Ireland (f**k off)
Scotland
Asia/Pacific 1 (probably one of Tonga or Samoa 
Europe 2

Couldn't have went much worse tbh.

We got the easiest team in pool 4, surely thats something (loser of Tonga / Samoa plays off against top Asian side probably S Korea for the place) :D

Pool 1 NZ would have been worst, Wales best and not much between SA & Eng - the Saffers were a good laugh in Newcastle in 2015 so will take that and hoefully get tickets to that game in France.

Wouldn't have wanted France in pool 2, I hate the Irish so beating them good - surely in 2 years we can come up with a plan to beat 1 team!!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Pool D in 2019: Wales, Australia, Fiji, Georgia, Uruguay

Pool C in 2023: Wales, Australia, Fiji, Europe 1 (almost certainly Georgia), Repechage (quite possibly Uruguay)


Pool A in 2019: Japan, Ireland, Scotland, Samoa, Russia

Pool B in 2023: South Africa, Ireland, Scotland, Asia-Pacific 1 (quite possibly Samoa), Europe 2 (quite possibly Russia)


Pool C in 2019: England, France, Argentina, Tonga, USA

Pool D in 2023: England, Japan, Argentina, Oceania 1 (quite possibly Tonga), Americas 2 (quite possibly USA)


Pool B in 2019: New Zealand, South Africa, Italy, Namibia, Canada

Pool A in 2023: New Zealand, France, Italy, Africa 1 (almost certainly Namibia), Americas 1 (quite possibly Canada)




Basically shuffled 3 teams.

Not to mention drawing it almost 3yrs ahead.

What an utterly laughable system.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

6 minutes ago, HibeeJibee said:

Pool D in 2019: Wales, Australia, Fiji, Georgia, Uruguay

Pool C in 2023: Wales, Australia, Fiji, Europe 1 (almost certainly Georgia), Repechage (quite possibly Uruguay)


Pool A in 2019: Japan, Ireland, Scotland, Samoa, Russia

Pool B in 2023: South Africa, Ireland, Scotland, Asia-Pacific 1 (quite possibly Samoa), Europe 2 (quite possibly Russia)


Pool C in 2019: England, France, Argentina, Tonga, USA

Pool D in 2023: England, Japan, Argentina, Oceania 1 (quite possibly Tonga), Americas 2 (quite possibly USA)


Pool B in 2019: New Zealand, South Africa, Italy, Namibia, Canada

Pool A in 2023: New Zealand, France, Italy, Africa 1 (almost certainly Namibia), Americas 1 (quite possibly Canada)




Basically shuffled 3 teams.

Not to mention drawing it almost 3yrs ahead.

What an utterly laughable system.

As its quite likely to be the same 20 teams again and the seeding doesn't change that much it was likely to happen.

Form the last seeding, only Ireland swapped places with South Africa, and Scotland swapped with Japan.

Last time though Georgia were direct qualifiers and Fiji were Oceania 1 qualifier for example so the same but different

 I think (hoping) there will be a few changes ie Canada wont win the Americas qualifying, infact will be lucky to get 2nd. Im hoping we might see a few changes in the teams, maybe Kenya or Zimbabwe (Algeria could be a wild card if they can entice all their French based players to play the qualifiers) can pip Namibia for the African spot, and Europe 2 could go to Russia, Romania or Spain.

Having more that half the teams as direct qualifiers means that the Tier 2's miss out on games against the tier 1's in qualifying. If you went back to only the semi finalist qualfied direct and were the top 4 seeds, you would have for example Australia in the qualifiers with Fiji, Tonga and Samoa who they hardly play at the moment, Scotland, Ireland, France and Italy, lining up against Georgia, Romania, Spain, Russia, Belgium, Portugal etc Granted to start with the matches would be 1 sided, but at least these countries would be getting games against the top sides on a more regular basis

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Obviously some new qualifiers would be good... That said the same teams dominate regional qualifying every time (Namibia, USA/Canada, Uruguay etc.).

Over last 20yrs literally only variation has been 1 of Portugal/Russia/Uruguay each time. (EDIT: plus Romania's 2019 disqualification). Russia  have been only new face in last decade and a non-European debutant won't have been seen in almost quarter of a century!

Plus they manipulate continental quotas. Pacific islands bombed RWC 2015 meaning none qualified automatically: so bumped their slots for 2019 at Europe/Asia's expense (Japan = hosts).

When draw isn't mixing same old faces up, either - very underwhelming.

Edited by HibeeJibee
Link to comment
Share on other sites

57 minutes ago, HibeeJibee said:

Obviously some new qualifiers would be good... That said the same teams dominate regional qualifying every time (Namibia, USA/Canada, Uruguay etc.).

Over last 20yrs literally only variation has been 1 of Portugal/Russia/Uruguay each time. (EDIT: plus Romania's 2019 disqualification). Russia  have been only new face in last decade and a non-European debutant won't have been seen in almost quarter of a century!

Plus they manipulate continental quotas. Pacific islands bombed RWC 2015 meaning none qualified automatically: so bumped their slots for 2019 at Europe/Asia's expense (Japan = hosts).

When draw isn't mixing same old faces up, either - very underwhelming.

There are a few countries there or there abouts In the Americas Chile and Brazil are improving as they get to play in the Americas 6 nations now with Argentina, Uruguay, USA and Canada, Brazil have already picked up wins against Canada and the USA, if the SLAR picks up next year that will give them a boost.

Not wanting to sound too cliche, if there was a bit less corruption and govt interference the likes of Kenya, Zimbabwe and Uganda could be pushing Namibia, Madagascar as well get 40-50k at their home games, Algeria and Morroco could probably put together fantastic teams if the french clubs let them

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I think the worst part of the draw is that even if we do get through, it's to play NZ or France. To be honest, you don't know how good anyone is going to be in 2023 right now anyway, so no point worrying about it!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

9 hours ago, flyingscot said:

Glasgow are regressing badly. SRU will be anxiously watching season ticket renewals now...

To think they are still trying to punt this "warrior nation" bullshit where if you give them £25 now, they might allow you to buy a £30 ticket to a zebre game in the future.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

In a way you fee sorry for Wilson as he has not been able to play his 2 big summer signings in Grey and Nakarawa and this season was seen as a bit of a write off before it started, but if there isn't a serious show of intent for next season in the form of a big name (or at least half decent) stand off and full back for starters, and probably a clear out of 15-20 players.

If they act now the majority of the Jauguares squad are looking for a new club as the wages on offer in the SLAR will be tiny in comparison to what Glasgow can offer, and they could be picking the bones of the Chetahs and Kings if there is anything left to pick.

With the SA teams entering next year they need to act soon or risk being pushed back down to being an irrelevance

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Unfortunately, your content contains terms that we do not allow. Please edit your content to remove the highlighted words below.
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...